Unit 05  ·  The eBook  ·  AP World History: Modern

Revolutions

Ten chapters for ten topics, and one argument connecting the political half to the industrial one. A set of writers claimed that authority comes from the governed and that rights belong to people as such, and then wrote those claims down, where everyone they excluded could read them. The rest of the unit is what happened as revolutionaries, the enslaved, nationalists, women and factory workers each held that principle to its own terms, against states that were simultaneously being remade by coal.

10 chapters 48 sections Read straight through or jump to a chapter

Contents

  1. 5.1 By What Right? Topic 5.1  ·  5 sections
  2. 5.2 How Revolutions Made Nations Topic 5.2  ·  5 sections
  3. 5.3 Coal, Water, and One Roof Topic 5.3  ·  5 sections
  4. 5.4 Who Made the World's Goods? Topic 5.4  ·  5 sections
  5. 5.5 More Power, Longer Reach Topic 5.5  ·  5 sections
  6. 5.6 Industry on Purpose Topic 5.6  ·  5 sections
  7. 5.7 Freer Trade, Bigger Business Topic 5.7  ·  5 sections
  8. 5.8 Calls for Change Topic 5.8  ·  5 sections
  9. 5.9 A City Built for a Quarter of Itself Topic 5.9  ·  4 sections
  10. 5.10 The Question That Runs Both Ways Topic 5.10  ·  4 sections
Topic 5.1

By What Right?

In 1750 most rulers said their power came from God. A group of writers began asking every old authority the same question, by what right?, and answered it with reason, natural rights and the consent of the people. This chapter follows that question from the new science of the late 1600s to the reformers of the 1800s, and asks how much it had changed by 1900.

Go to the Topic 5.1 lesson  ·  Back to contents

How to Use This

The College Board asks two things of this topic. First, explain the ideas that formed the context of the revolutions that swept the Atlantic world. Second, explain how the Enlightenment affected societies over time. Sections 01 to 03 answer the first; sections 04 and 05 answer the second. Each section ends with a tool, a limit and a comparison you can use in an answer.

  1. 01 A new way of knowing: the old answer, and the method that questioned it.
  2. 02 The new answers: natural rights, the social contract, limits on power, and toleration.
  3. 03 The ideas travel: how they spread, why they came before the revolutions, and how the people became a nation.
  4. 04 Pressing the words further: abolition, the end of serfdom and the vote, 1787 to 1888.
  5. 05 Women's demands, and what stayed: de Gouges, Wollstonecraft, Seneca Falls, and the world of 1900.
  6. Then the closing section, which gathers the evidence for an answer.
01

A New Way of Knowing

1680s to 1780s  ·  Reason and evidence

The Enlightenment's political ideas began with a method. Thinkers learned to test claims about nature with reason and evidence, and then asked whether the same method could test the claims that kings, churches and nobles made about their own power.

The old answer

In 1750 most of Europe's rulers gave the same answer to the question "who does a state belong to?" It belonged to the king, because God had put him there. This is divine right, the claim Louis XIV made at Versailles (Topic 3.2). In most countries one church was the law: Catholic in France and Spain, Anglican in England. Nobles were born into privileges, such as freedom from some taxes, and across much of central and eastern Europe peasants were serfs, bound to work their lord's land. Authority came from God, from tradition and from birth.

Reason and evidence, first for nature

In 1687 the English scientist Isaac Newton published a book showing that a few laws of motion and gravity, worked out with mathematics and tested against what astronomers observed, explained both the paths of the planets and the fall of an apple. The lesson many readers took from it was that the world runs by laws a human mind can discover, without being told by an old book or a priest.

In 1689 the English philosopher John Locke argued that every idea in our minds comes from experience. At birth, he wrote, the mind is like "white paper." Learning from evidence and experience instead of accepting what authorities say is called empiricism. Scientific lectures and experiments became popular entertainment for people who could pay, like the family in Joseph Wright's painting of an air-pump experiment, made famous by a print of 1769.

Then for people

The step that made the method political was simple to state. If reason and evidence can explain the planets, can they explain people: how we should live together, what a government is for, and what makes a ruler's power rightful? Enlightenment writers turned the method on government, religion, law and society, and that is where the new political ideas came from.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Name the method before the ideas. The Enlightenment applied reason and evidence first to nature, then to human relationships, and that is why its political ideas challenged authority instead of simply disagreeing with it.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
The method was shared by a small, mostly wealthy and literate group in 1750. Most people still learned what was true from their church and their community.
Comparison hook
Against divine right in Topic 3.2: Louis XIV's claim rested on God's choice and could not be tested. An empiricist asks for evidence.

Terms to use precisely

Divine right
The claim that a king's power comes from God, so no one may question or remove him.
Serf
A peasant bound to a lord's land, who owed the lord labor and could not leave freely.
Empiricism
Learning from evidence and experience instead of accepting what authorities say.
Deism
The belief that God created the world and then let it run by natural laws.
02

The New Answers

1689 to 1763  ·  Locke, Montesquieu, Rousseau, Voltaire

Enlightenment writers started with the individual person, not the king, and came up with new answers to the question of what makes power rightful. The change was not that kings disappeared; it was that a ruler now had to answer the question.

Natural rights and the social contract

In his Second Treatise of Government (1689), Locke argued that people are born free and equal, with natural rights to their "lives, liberties and estates" (an estate is what you own). No government gives these rights, and no government may take them. People form a government to protect them.

That makes government an agreement, a social contract. "No one," Locke wrote, can be "subjected to the political power of another, without his own consent." And if a government tries to destroy the people's rights or reduce them to slavery, it puts itself "into a state of war with the people," who no longer owe it obedience. Most historians think Locke wrote most of the book in the early 1680s, when some members of Parliament were trying to keep the Catholic James from becoming king, and he published it in 1689, just after Parliament had replaced James II. Both times, his argument defended the right to resist a king.

In 1762 Jean-Jacques Rousseau, a writer from Geneva who lived in France, began The Social Contract with a famous line: "Man is born free; and everywhere he is in chains." Rousseau argued that rightful power comes from the "general will" of the people as a whole, a more collective idea than Locke's.

Limits on power

In The Spirit of the Laws (1748), the French writer Montesquieu argued that liberty is safest when the power to make laws, the power to carry them out and the power to judge are held by different people, so that one power can check another. This is the separation of powers.

Religion and the state

In 1762 a court in Toulouse condemned Jean Calas, a Protestant cloth merchant, for killing his son to stop him from becoming a Catholic. His son had most likely taken his own life. Calas was tortured and executed. Voltaire, one of the most famous writers in Europe, took up the case, published a Treatise on Tolerance in 1763, and campaigned until Calas was declared innocent in 1765. The argument was religious toleration: no government should force a faith on anyone or punish people for what they believe.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Say what made a ruler legitimate, before and after. The old answer was God and birth; the new answer was reason and the consent of the people.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
The writers disagreed. Locke protected individual rights; Rousseau stressed the people as a whole; few of them wanted to abolish kings, and most did not mean their words for everyone (section 04).
Comparison hook
Against the Mandate of Heaven: Chinese rulers could also lose the right to rule by governing badly, but the mandate still came from Heaven. Locke's consent comes from the people.

Terms to use precisely

Natural rights
Rights people are born with, such as life, liberty and property, which no government gives or may take away.
Social contract
The idea that government is an agreement: people accept a government so that it will protect their rights.
Separation of powers
Dividing the powers to make laws, carry them out and judge among different people, so no one holds them all.
Religious toleration
The idea that no government should force a faith on anyone or punish people for their beliefs.
03

The Ideas Travel, Before the Revolutions

1751 to 1810  ·  Print, salons, letters

The ideas spread through print and conversation across Europe and the Atlantic, questioned tradition in every part of life, and came before the revolutions that began in 1775, 1789, 1791 and 1810. They gave revolutionaries their words, and they turned "the people" into the nation.

Print, salons and letters

From 1751 to 1772, Denis Diderot and his partners published the Encyclopédie in Paris: seventeen volumes of articles and eleven of pictures that tried to explain everything by reason, from how to make glass or mount a fan to what a government owes its people. The French government banned it in 1759, and the Pope condemned it, but the last ten volumes of articles came out together in 1765, and printers in other countries copied it: a second edition was printed in Lucca, Italy, from 1758.

The ideas also traveled in newspapers and pamphlets, in London's coffeehouses, in letters between writers across Europe and the Americas, and in the conversation gatherings of Paris called salons, which were often run by women. In 1784 the German philosopher Immanuel Kant summed up the attitude in a motto: "Dare to know," which he explained as having the courage to use your own understanding.

Before the revolutions

The College Board's words are that Enlightenment thought "often preceded" revolutions. The American Revolution began in 1775, the French Revolution in 1789, the Haitian Revolution in 1791, and the wars of independence in Spanish America in 1810. In Bogotá, Antonio Nariño secretly printed a Spanish translation of France's new declaration of rights (in 1793 or 1794) and was arrested for it in 1794; he later became one of the leaders of New Granada's independence.

The people become a nation

If a state belongs to its people, a new question follows: which people? More and more, the answer was the nation, a people who saw themselves as one (Topic 5.2 explains what held a nation together). In 1789 the French revolutionaries wrote that "the principle of all sovereignty resides essentially in the nation." Over the next century, nationalism, loyalty to your nation above a king or an empire, became one of the strongest forces shaping states and empires: it helped build new countries and pulled at empires of many peoples. Topic 5.2 tells that story.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Context, not cause. Enlightenment ideas spread and came before the revolutions, so they are the intellectual and ideological context the revolutions happened in.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Most people in 1789 could not read the Encyclopédie. They met the ideas, if at all, through talk, sermons, pamphlets and rumor.
Comparison hook
Against the printing press of the 1400s: the technology was old by 1750. What was new was how much was printed, and the network of readers, salons and letters around it.

Terms to use precisely

Encyclopédie
The French encyclopedia of 1751 to 1772, edited by Diderot, which explained everything by reason and was banned and printed anyway.
Salon
A conversation gathering in a private home, often run by a woman, where writers and readers discussed ideas.
Sovereignty
The highest power in a state.
Nationalism
Loyalty to your nation, a people who see themselves as one, above a king or an empire.
04

Pressing the Words Further

1787 to 1888  ·  Abolition, serfs, voters

The words sounded like everyone, but the men who wrote them often did not mean everyone. Over the next century, reform movements driven by Enlightenment ideas and by religious faith pressed the same words until rights reached the enslaved, the serfs and many more voters, slowly and unevenly.

The words were bigger than their writers

Locke owned shares in the Royal African Company, an English company that traded enslaved Africans, in the 1670s. Rousseau wrote in Emile (1762) that "a woman's education must therefore be planned in relation to man." Most of the men who wrote and read the new ideas did not mean them for women, enslaved Africans or peasants, though a few did: the French philosopher Condorcet argued for women's rights in 1790. Yet the words were written down, and anyone could ask the philosophers' own question: by what right am I left out?

Abolition: ideas and faith together

In 1787 twelve men in London, nine of them Quakers, a Christian group whose members had come to see slavery as a sin, founded the Society for Effecting the Abolition of the Slave Trade. Its seal showed a kneeling African man in chains and the words "Am I not a man and a brother?", and the potter Josiah Wedgwood turned it into a medallion that supporters wore. Olaudah Equiano, who had been enslaved, published his life story in 1789 and traveled across Britain speaking against the trade.

Abolition came country by country. Britain banned the slave trade in 1807. In 1834 it began ending slavery in most of its empire, though freed people had to keep working for their former owners as unpaid "apprentices" until 1838. France abolished slavery in its colonies in 1794, brought it back in 1802, and ended it again in 1848. Brazil was the last country in the Americas, in 1888. The enslaved people of Saint-Domingue ended slavery there by revolution, which is Topic 5.2.

Serfs and voters

Serfdom ended too. In 1848 the Austrian Empire freed its peasants from the forced labor they owed their lords. In 1861 Tsar Alexander II of Russia freed more than 20 million serfs. He had reportedly told Russian nobles in 1856 that it was better to end serfdom "from above" than to wait for it to end "from below," and Russia's defeat in the Crimean War pushed him too. The freed serfs had to pay for their land over many years.

Suffrage, the right to vote, widened in steps. In 1848 France gave the vote to all adult men. Britain widened voting among men in 1832, 1867 and 1884, and even then many men could not vote.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Name both engines. The reform movements were driven by Enlightenment ideas about natural rights and by religious faith, and they took decades.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Ending slavery or serfdom in law did not end hard labor or poverty. Freed people and freed serfs often stayed poor, and other kinds of forced labor went on in many places.
Comparison hook
Against Topic 4.4: the plantation economy had made the Atlantic slave trade huge. By 1888 every country in the Americas had abolished slavery in law.

Terms to use precisely

Abolition
Ending slavery, or ending the slave trade, by law.
Quakers
A Christian group whose members, by the late 1700s, led some of the first campaigns against slavery.
Serfdom
A system in which peasants were bound to the land and owed labor to a lord.
Suffrage
The right to vote.
05

Women's Demands, and What Stayed

1791 to 1900  ·  De Gouges, Wollstonecraft, Seneca Falls

Women pressed the same words too, because the men who wrote about the rights of man often meant only men. Their demands challenged both political and gender hierarchies. By 1900 much had changed, and much had not.

Three demands

In September 1791 the French writer Olympe de Gouges rewrote France's declaration of rights as the Declaration of the Rights of Woman and of the Female Citizen. Where the declaration of 1789 said "men are born and remain free and equal in rights," her first article said: "Woman is born free and remains equal to man in rights." The revolutionary government executed her in November 1793.

In 1792 the English writer Mary Wollstonecraft published A Vindication of the Rights of Woman. She quoted Rousseau, who had warned that if women were educated like men, "the less power will they have over us," and answered: "I do not wish them to have power over men; but over themselves." Her claim was that women can reason, so they must be educated to think and decide for themselves.

In 1840 the American abolitionist Lucretia Mott, a Quaker minister, went to an antislavery convention in London as a delegate and was refused a seat because she was a woman. Elizabeth Cady Stanton, there with her husband, a delegate, sat with Mott and the other women, apart from the men. In July 1848 the two of them, with three other women, organized a women's rights convention in Seneca Falls, New York. Its Declaration of Sentiments, drafted by Stanton with members of the M'Clintock family, copied the Declaration of Independence and added two words: "all men and women are created equal." It complained that a woman had never been "permitted ... to exercise her inalienable right to the elective franchise," the vote. The resolution demanding the vote was the only one not passed unanimously; one hundred women and men signed the declaration.

This was feminism emerging: the claim that women and men should have equal rights. It challenged political hierarchy, who votes and who rules, and gender hierarchy, who is in charge at home and under the law. Under the law of the time, the Seneca Falls declaration complained, a married woman was "civilly dead."

What stayed by 1900

By 1900, kings and emperors still ruled most of Europe and much of the world, many of them sharing power with elected parliaments. Slavery had been abolished across the Americas, but other kinds of forced labor went on in many places. Many countries let some or all men vote. Women could vote in national elections almost nowhere: New Zealand, in 1893, was the first self-governing country where all adult women could vote in national elections.

So the Enlightenment changed the answer to "who does a state belong to?": to its people, by reason and consent, not to a king by God's will. The question it taught people to ask kept working long after the philosophers were gone. That is the change. How slowly the rights reached, and how many people were still waiting in 1900, is the continuity.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Compare a claim to the words it borrows. De Gouges and the Seneca Falls declaration kept the old words and changed who they covered: that is a change and a continuity in one sentence.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
The women at Seneca Falls were mostly white and middle class, and their declaration spoke for some women more than others. Name whose voice a source carries.
Comparison hook
Against the 1789 declaration: same words, a wider claim. Describe what each one argues for and against.

Terms to use precisely

Feminism
The claim that women and men should have equal rights.
Declaration of Sentiments
The 1848 Seneca Falls declaration that copied the Declaration of Independence and added "and women."
Elective franchise
The right to vote in elections.
Hierarchy
A ranking of people, with some above others in power or status.

Building an Answer That Scores

Each card gathers the evidence for one part of the answer. The first two answer Learning Objective A, the ideas as the context of the revolutions; the last two answer Learning Objective B, what the Enlightenment did to societies over time.

Continuity and Change

The question changed before the kings did

Before the Enlightenment, rulers said their power came from God, tradition and birth. Locke argued in 1689 that people are born with natural rights and that no one may be put under a government's power without consent; Montesquieu (1748) argued for the separation of powers, and Voltaire (1763) for religious toleration. What changed was what made a ruler legitimate. What continued was that kings still ruled almost everywhere.

Context

The ideas came before the revolutions

The ideas spread through the Encyclopédie (1751 to 1772, banned in France and reprinted in Italy), salons, coffeehouses and letters, and came before the revolutions of 1775, 1789, 1791 and 1810. Nariño's printed translation of the French declaration in Bogotá shows them crossing the Atlantic. If a state belongs to its people, the people could be the nation, and nationalism became a major force of the 1800s.

Continuity and Change

Reformers pressed the words further, slowly

Driven by natural rights and by faith, reformers founded the London antislavery society of 1787 (nine of its twelve founders were Quakers). Britain began ending slavery in most of its empire in 1834 and Brazil, last in the Americas, in 1888. Serfdom ended in Austria in 1848 and Russia in 1861; France gave all adult men the vote in 1848. Each change took decades.

Claims and Evidence

Women kept the words and changed who they covered

De Gouges (1791) wrote that "woman is born free and remains equal to man in rights"; Wollstonecraft (1792) wanted women to have power "over themselves"; the Seneca Falls declaration (1848) said "all men and women are created equal" and demanded the vote. Their claims challenged political and gender hierarchies, but by 1900 women could vote in national elections almost nowhere.

Topic 5.2

How Revolutions Made Nations

By 1789 the new ideas about rights were everywhere educated people read, but ideas alone never overthrew a king. This chapter follows four revolutions, in America, France, Haiti and Spanish America, asks what caused each one and what it created, and then follows the loyalty they left behind, to the nation, through the rest of the 1800s.

Go to the Topic 5.2 lesson  ·  Back to contents

How to Use This

The College Board asks you to explain the causes and effects of the revolutions between 1750 and 1900. Sections 01 to 04 take the four revolutions of the Atlantic world one at a time, each with its grievance, its words, its chance and what it created. Section 05 follows two lasting effects, new ideas about government and the nation, to 1878. Each section ends with a tool, a limit and a comparison you can use in an answer.

  1. 01 The recipe, and America: why ideas were not enough, and the first of the four revolutions to win.
  2. 02 France: how America's war became France's chance, and what France made of it.
  3. 03 Haiti: the words of 1789, claimed by the people they were not written for.
  4. 04 Spanish America: an empire with no king, and Haiti's help.
  5. 05 New ideas, and the nation: liberalism, democracy, and the loyalty that joined Italy and Germany and pulled the Balkans away from the Ottoman Empire.
  6. Then the closing section, which gathers the evidence for an answer.
01

The Recipe, and America

1763 to 1787  ·  Grievance, words, chance

Many people read Enlightenment writers and went on obeying their kings. A revolution came when three things met: a grievance many people felt, the words to name it, and a chance to act. America had all three first.

Why ideas were not enough

Topic 5.1 showed that the new ideas about natural rights and the consent of the people had spread across Europe and the Americas by 1789. But reading a book is not the same as risking your life. Across this topic, three ingredients turn up again and again. The first is a grievance: a wrong that many people feel, such as an unfair tax, a privilege for a few, slavery, or a law that shuts people out of power. The second is the words: a document that names the grievance in the language of rights, something people can read aloud and rally around. The third is a chance: a moment when the old ruler is broke, far away, at war, or gone.

The grievance and the words

Britain won the Seven Years' War in 1763, but it came out of the war deep in debt. Parliament decided its thirteen American colonies should help pay for the soldiers who guarded them, and it taxed them with laws such as the Sugar Act of 1764 and the Stamp Act of 1765, which taxed newspapers, legal papers and playing cards. The colonists had no members in Parliament, so they answered with a slogan: "no taxation without representation." Protest reached ordinary homes: English potters even sold colonists teapots painted "No Stamp Act."

On 4 July 1776 the Continental Congress adopted the Declaration of Independence. It argued that "all men are created equal," that governments get "their just powers from the consent of the governed," and that when a government destroys people's rights, "it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it." That is the social contract from Topic 5.1, turned into a reason to break away.

The chance, and what it created

Britain was an ocean away, and its victory in 1763 had pushed France out of North America, so the colonists no longer needed British soldiers to protect them. Once the fighting began in 1775, France, Britain's old rival, joined the war on the American side in 1778 with money, soldiers and a navy, which helped the colonists win. By 1783 Britain had recognized the independence of the United States. In 1787 the new country wrote a constitution for a republic: a country with no king, whose leaders are elected.

The College Board calls the American Revolution and its republic "a model and inspiration for a number of the revolutions that followed." It was also limited. The republic kept slavery, and most states let only men who owned property vote.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Name all three ingredients, with a detail for each. Ask what the colonists were angry about, which document named it, and why they could act when they did.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
The revolution's "all men are created equal" did not end slavery, and the new states limited voting to some men.
Comparison hook
Against France (section 02): the American revolutionaries broke away from a ruler across an ocean; the French remade their own kingdom.

Terms to use precisely

Grievance
A wrong that many people feel, such as an unfair tax or a law that shuts them out.
Stamp Act
A 1765 British tax on printed papers in the American colonies, repealed in 1766.
Consent of the governed
The idea that a government's rightful power comes from the people who live under it.
Republic
A country with no king, whose leaders are elected.
02

France: The Bill Comes Due

1788 to 1804  ·  A kingdom remade

France's help was crucial to the American victory, and paying for it, on top of older war debts, pushed the French king to the edge of bankruptcy. One revolution's effect became the next one's chance.

The chance came from America

France had spent heavily on the American war, on top of the debts of earlier wars, and by 1788 King Louis XVI's government was nearly bankrupt. To raise new taxes, the king called the Estates-General, an assembly of the three "estates" of France: the clergy, the nobles, and everyone else. It had not met since 1614.

The grievance

The first two estates had privileges. The clergy and the nobles paid little in taxes, and the Third Estate, most of the people of France, from rich lawyers to poor peasants, paid most of them. After a bad harvest in 1788, the price of bread, the main food of the poor, soared. When the Estates-General met in May 1789, the Third Estate refused to be outvoted by the other two, and in June it declared itself the National Assembly. On 14 July a Paris crowd stormed the Bastille, a royal fortress and prison, to seize its gunpowder.

The words

In August 1789 the Assembly ended the nobles' special privileges and adopted the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen. Its first article reads, "Men are born and remain free and equal in rights." Its third reads, "The principle of all sovereignty resides essentially in the nation." Sovereignty is the highest power in a state, and the declaration said it belonged to the nation, not to the king.

What it created

France abolished its monarchy in 1792 and became a republic, and in January 1793 it executed the king. At war with much of Europe and afraid of enemies at home, the government began the Terror (1793 to 1794), during which it killed thousands of people it called enemies of the revolution. In 1799 a general, Napoleon Bonaparte, took power, and in 1804 he crowned himself emperor. His armies carried the revolution's laws, such as the end of noble privilege, across Europe, and they also made many Europeans hate French rule.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Show the link. Trace how the American war reached Paris: what did it cost France, and what did that force the king to do?
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
The revolution that began against a king ended with an emperor, and the Terror killed thousands in the name of the people.
Comparison hook
Against Haiti (section 03): the same declaration that France wrote for itself was claimed by people France held in slavery.

Terms to use precisely

Estates-General
France's old assembly of clergy, nobles and commoners, called in 1788 to meet in May 1789, for the first time since 1614.
Third Estate
Everyone in France who was not clergy or noble: most of the people.
Sovereignty
The highest power in a state.
The Terror
The years 1793 to 1794, when France's revolutionary government executed thousands of people it called enemies.
03

Haiti: The Words Claimed

1791 to 1825  ·  Saint-Domingue becomes Haiti

France's declaration said men are born free and equal. In Saint-Domingue, the people France held in slavery claimed those words for themselves, rose up first, and won a country of their own.

The grievance

Saint-Domingue, on the western part of the Caribbean island of Hispaniola, was France's most valuable colony. Its sugar and coffee were grown by enslaved Africans and their children, worked and punished brutally on plantations. Around 1789 the colony held more than 400,000 enslaved people and fewer than 80,000 free people, white colonists and free people of color (free people of African or mixed descent) together: more than five enslaved people for every free person.

The words, and the chance

When the 1789 declaration reached the colony, free people of color asked the Assembly in Paris for the equal rights it promised. The Assembly left the question to the colonists, and the white planters refused. In 1790 a free man of color, Vincent Ogé, led a small revolt for those rights, and early in 1791 he was executed. Paris granted free people of color equal rights only in April 1792, after the revolution in the colony had begun.

With France in revolution and the colony's white planters divided, enslaved people in the northern plain rose up in August 1791. They burned plantations across the northern plain. Toussaint Louverture, who had been born enslaved and had won his freedom before the revolution, became the revolution's most famous leader. In 1793, fighting on Spain's side against France, he announced: "I want Liberty and Equality to reign in Saint Domingue."

What it created

In 1802 Napoleon brought slavery back in other French colonies, such as Guadeloupe, and sent an army to retake Saint-Domingue. Toussaint was arrested and died in a French prison in the mountains in 1803. His officer Jean-Jacques Dessalines fought on, and yellow fever and the war destroyed the French army. On 1 January 1804 Dessalines declared independence and gave the country its old Taíno name, Haiti.

Haiti was the second independent country in the Americas, after the United States, and the first founded by people who had freed themselves from slavery. Its effects reached other countries. In April 1803, with his army in Saint-Domingue dying of yellow fever and a new war with Britain coming, Napoleon sold Louisiana to the United States. Countries that allowed slavery feared Haiti's example: the United States did not recognize Haiti until 1862, and in 1825 France demanded 150 million francs, later cut to 90 million, as the price of recognizing Haiti's independence. And in 1816 Haiti helped the next revolution (section 04).

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Say who acted. Ask who rose up in 1791, who led them, and whose army they defeated, before you mention any law passed in Paris.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Haiti paid for its independence: in money to France, and in years of isolation by countries that allowed slavery.
Comparison hook
Against the United States (section 01): both broke from a European empire, but only Haiti's revolution ended slavery.

Terms to use precisely

Saint-Domingue
France's Caribbean sugar and coffee colony, which became Haiti in 1804.
Free people of color
Free people of African or mixed descent in the colonies, who had property but not equal rights.
Toussaint Louverture
A formerly enslaved man who became the most famous leader of the Haitian Revolution.
Jean-Jacques Dessalines
Toussaint's officer, who declared Haiti's independence on 1 January 1804.
04

Spanish America: An Empire With No King

1808 to 1826  ·  Bolívar and the new states

Creoles in Spain's American empire had grievances for decades. Their chance came when Napoleon, the French Revolution's general, took Spain's king, and the last revolution's creation, Haiti, helped them win.

The grievance

In Spain's American empire, creoles, people of Spanish descent born in the Americas, owned land, mines and businesses, but the highest offices in the church, the army and the government went to peninsulares, men born in Spain. Spain also controlled what the colonies could grow, make and trade. Simón Bolívar, a creole from a rich Caracas family, wrote that Spain "has kept us in a sort of permanent infancy with regard to public affairs": treated like children, kept out of running their own affairs.

The chance

In 1808 Napoleon invaded Spain and forced its king from the throne, putting his own brother in his place. Spanish America suddenly had no rightful king to obey. In 1810 creole leaders set up governments of their own, in Caracas and in Buenos Aires, at first in the name of the captive king, and many soon moved to full independence. In Mexico a priest, Miguel Hidalgo, called on Native and mestizo villagers to rise up.

The words, and help from Haiti

The wars went badly at first. In 1815, beaten and in exile on the British island of Jamaica, Bolívar wrote a long letter to a British reader, now called the Letter from Jamaica. "The hatred that the Peninsula has inspired in us," he wrote, "is greater than the ocean between us," and the tie to Spain "has been severed." He also doubted that governments "wholly representative," chosen entirely by the people's votes, suited Spanish America yet.

Then Haiti helped. In 1816 Haiti's president, Alexandre Pétion, gave Bolívar guns, supplies and men for a new expedition, and asked him in return to end slavery in the lands he freed.

What it created

By 1826 Spain had lost every colony in the Americas except Cuba and Puerto Rico. Mexico, Gran Colombia, Peru, Chile, the provinces of the Río de la Plata and others became independent countries, and Brazil broke away from Portugal in 1822 with an emperor of its own. Creole elites took the top places. Most of the new countries kept a sharp social hierarchy, and slavery lasted in several of them for decades: Colombia ended it in 1851, Venezuela and Peru in 1854.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Use the chain. Connect two revolutions: what did events in Spain in 1808 do to Spanish America, and what did Haiti give Bolívar in 1816?
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Independence changed who ruled more than how society was ordered: creoles replaced peninsulares at the top.
Comparison hook
Against the Declaration of Independence: read the two side by side and ask what each says about who should govern, and why the answers might differ.

Terms to use precisely

Creoles
People of Spanish descent born in the Americas.
Peninsulares
Men born in Spain, who held the highest offices in Spain's American empire.
Letter from Jamaica
Bolívar's 1815 letter arguing that Spanish America would never return to Spain.
Mestizo
A person of mixed Native and European descent.
05

New Ideas, and the Nation

1789 to 1878  ·  Liberalism, democracy, nationalism

Some of the revolutions' longest-lasting effects were ideas: new answers to how a country should be run, and a new loyalty, to the nation, that joined some states together and pulled peoples away from empires.

New ways to govern

Behind all four revolutions was anger at kings and empires, and the revolutions left behind new answers to an old question: how should a country be run? One was the republic, with a written constitution, a set of basic laws that even the government must follow. Another was liberalism: the belief that a constitution and an elected parliament should limit the government and protect each person's rights, such as free speech, a free press and property. Many liberals in the 1800s still wanted only men with property to vote. A third was democracy, rule by the people, which pushed for the vote to reach all men.

These ideas did not stay on paper. They helped set off new revolutions across Europe in 1830 and 1848, when crowds demanded constitutions, parliaments and wider voting. Most of the uprisings of 1848 were crushed within two years, but the demands did not go away.

From "the people" to the nation

The revolutions said that a state belongs to its people. That raised a new question: which people? More and more, people answered with the nation: everyone who shared a language, a religion, customs and a homeland. Nationalism put loyalty to the nation above loyalty to a king or an empire.

Governments learned to use that loyalty. In 1793, at war with much of Europe, revolutionary France ordered that "all Frenchmen are in permanent requisition for the service of the armies": young men would fight, married men would make weapons, women would make tents and work in hospitals, and old people would go to public squares to preach "the unity of the Republic." But nationalism could also be turned against a government, by people who felt they were a nation without a country of their own.

Nationalism joins states

Italy was split into several states, some ruled by Austria. Italian nationalists, among them Count Cavour, the chief minister of the kingdom of Piedmont-Sardinia, and the soldier Giuseppe Garibaldi, whose volunteers took Sicily and Naples in 1860, joined most of Italy into one kingdom in 1861, and added Rome in 1870. Joining states into one is called unification.

Germany was split into more than thirty states. In 1848 German liberals met in Frankfurt to unite Germany with an elected parliament and a constitution, and failed. Then Otto von Bismarck, the chief minister of Prussia, told Prussia's lawmakers in 1862 that the great questions of the time are not decided "by speeches and majority resolutions," which had been "the big mistake of 1848 and 1849," but "by iron and blood." After three wars, against Denmark, Austria and France, the German Empire was proclaimed on 18 January 1871 in the Hall of Mirrors at Versailles, the palace Louis XIV built.

Nationalism breaks an empire

The Ottoman Empire ruled many peoples in the Balkans, in southeastern Europe, Muslim and Christian. Serbs rebelled and won the right to rule themselves. Greeks rose up in 1821, and in 1830 Britain, France and Russia declared Greece an independent state; it became a kingdom under a Bavarian prince in 1832. Other Balkan peoples followed, and in 1878 Serbia, Montenegro and Romania were recognized as independent.

The Ottoman government answered with a loyalty of its own, Ottomanism. In 1856 it promised equal treatment to all its subjects, Muslim or not, and in 1869 a law made every subject an Ottoman citizen. The idea was one loyalty for everyone, to the empire, instead of to a nation. It did not stop the Balkan nations from leaving. The idea reached beyond Europe, too: in the Spanish-ruled Philippines, Filipino writers in the Propaganda Movement of the 1880s and 1890s, José Rizal among them, demanded equal rights with Spaniards, and Spain executed Rizal in 1896, during a revolution against its rule.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Follow an effect forward. Start from the idea that a state belongs to its nation, then find one state it joined together and one people it pulled away from an empire, each with a date.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
A nation is imagined: people come to believe they belong to it. Many Italians in 1861 did not speak the same Italian, and Ottomanism's promise of equality was often not kept in practice.
Comparison hook
Against revolutionary France in 1793: France called on loyalty to the nation; the Ottoman government tried to build loyalty to the empire instead, to hold back nationalism.

Terms to use precisely

Liberalism
In the 1800s, the belief that a constitution and an elected parliament should limit the government and protect individual rights.
Democracy
Rule by the people; in the 1800s, the push to give all men the vote.
Nationalism
Loyalty to a nation, people who share a language, religion, customs and homeland, above a king or an empire.
Ottomanism
The Ottoman government's attempt to give all its peoples one loyalty, to the empire.

Building an Answer That Scores

Each card gathers the evidence for one part of the answer. The College Board asks for causes and effects, so the first two cards are causes and the last two are effects.

Causation

A grievance, the words and a chance

Evidence to sort: the Stamp Act (1765); the end of the French threat in North America (1763); the Declaration of Independence (1776); noble privilege and bread prices in France (1788 to 1789); a bankrupt French government (1788); the Declaration of the Rights of Man (1789); slavery in Saint-Domingue; the rising of 1791; Toussaint's proclamation (1793); creoles kept out of high office; Napoleon's invasion of Spain (1808); Bolívar's Letter from Jamaica (1815). For the revolution you choose, decide which is its grievance, which gave it words, and which was its chance.

Causation

Each revolution helped another start or win

Evidence to sort: France's spending on the American war; free people of color in Saint-Domingue and France's 1789 declaration; Napoleon's invasion of Spain (1808); Haiti's guns, supplies and men for Bolívar (1816). For each, name the two revolutions it links and decide whether it helped the second one start or helped it win. The College Board calls the American Revolution "a model and inspiration for a number of the revolutions that followed."

Effects

New states and new ideas about government

The United States (1783, a republic under the 1787 constitution), Haiti (1804) and the independent countries of Spanish America (by 1826) were new states. Republics, written constitutions, liberalism and democracy were new ideas, which helped set off new revolutions in Europe in 1830 and 1848. Many things stayed: slavery in the United States and much of Latin America, and creole elites at the top.

Effects

The nation, an effect that became a cause

Evidence to sort: France's 1793 order calling "all Frenchmen" to serve the armies; the liberals at Frankfurt (1848 to 1849); Bismarck's "iron and blood" (1862); Italy joined into one kingdom (1861), and Rome added (1870); the German Empire (1871); Britain, France and Russia declaring Greece independent (1830); Serbia, Montenegro and Romania recognized as independent (1878); the Ottoman edict of 1856 and the citizenship law of 1869. Decide which show nationalism joining states, which show it pulling peoples from an empire, and which show a government using or answering it.

Topic 5.3

Coal, Water, and One Roof

Even before Paris argued about rights, a different revolution had begun in Britain: a change in how things were made. This chapter asks why it began there. Part of the answer was in Britain's ground and water, and the rest was built by people. Then it follows the new workplace those causes produced, the factory, and the two things it changed about work.

Go to the Topic 5.3 lesson  ·  Back to contents

How to Use This

The College Board asks you to explain how environmental factors contributed to industrialization. Its list has seven factors. Sections 01 and 02 take the two that nature gave Britain; sections 03 and 04 take the five that people built, and show them working together; section 05 follows the new workplace they produced. Each section ends with a tool, a limit and a comparison you can use in an answer.

  1. 01 Coal, iron, and not enough wood: how a shortage of wood helped push Britain toward coal.
  2. 02 Water: moving heavy things cheaply, and turning wheels.
  3. 03 Food, people and towns: better farming, a growing population, and the towns it filled.
  4. 04 Laws, cotton and capital: three things that made the risk worth taking, and how the factors combined.
  5. 05 The factory: one place, and one job each.
  6. Then the closing section, which gathers the evidence for an answer.
01

Coal, Iron, and Not Enough Wood

1600s to 1709  ·  What nature gave

Britain had plenty of coal and iron, often close together and close to water, and too little wood. The shortage of wood pushed Britons to burn coal, and then to make iron with it.

How things were made in 1750

In 1750 almost everything people owned was made by hand. Most thread and cloth were made in homes. Under the putting-out system, a merchant brought raw wool or cotton to families in the countryside, who spun and wove it on their own wheels and looms, and he came back to collect the work and pay for each piece. Power came from human muscles, horses, wind and water wheels. Much of the world's cotton cloth came from India, and Britain's cotton makers grew up copying it.

Over the next century Britain built a new way of making things. The College Board lists seven factors that led to it. Two come from nature: waterways, and where coal, iron and timber were found. Five were built by people: towns, better farming, laws that protected property, resources from abroad, and saved-up money. This chapter takes them in that order.

Too little wood

By the 1600s most of Britain's old forests had been cut down, as a growing population cleared land for farms. Wood became expensive. That mattered, because wood was the fuel of the old economy. It heated homes, and it made charcoal, the fuel used to heat iron ore until the iron could be separated out. Much of the iron Britain used was bought from Sweden, and later from Russia, where forests were still large.

Britain did have coal, in huge beds, much of it close to the surface and close to rivers or the sea. So Britons burned coal instead of wood. By 1700 coal gave England about half of all its energy, much of it burned in fireplaces for heating and cooking.

Iron made with coal

Coal could not simply replace charcoal in an iron furnace: its impurities spoiled the iron. In 1709, at Coalbrookdale, a valley beside the River Severn in Shropshire, Abraham Darby made iron using coke, a fuel made by baking coal to drive the impurities off. Coalbrookdale had coal and iron ore close by and a river to carry what it made. At first coke iron was used mostly for cast-iron pots. It spread slowly, mainly after the 1750s, as charcoal iron and imported iron grew dearer, and over the following decades ironmakers learned to make better iron with coal.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Name the shortage and the substitute. Say what Britain lacked, what it used instead, and what that made possible.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Coal alone did not cause industry: other countries had coal, and coal had to be moved and used by people who could make it pay.
Comparison hook
Against water (section 02): coal gave heat and fuel; water gave cheap transport and power to turn wheels.

Terms to use precisely

Putting-out system
A way of making goods in which a merchant gives raw materials to families who work at home and pays them for each piece.
Charcoal
A fuel made by slowly burning wood, used to make iron before coke.
Coke
A fuel made by baking coal to drive off its impurities, used to make iron from 1709.
Timber
Wood from trees, used for fuel and building.
02

Water: Moving Heavy Things and Turning Wheels

1700s to 1761  ·  What nature gave, improved

Before railways, the cheapest way to move something heavy was to float it, and the fastest way to power a machine was a water wheel. Britain had coast, rivers and fast streams, and people added canals.

Coast, rivers and streams

Coal is heavy, and so is iron. Carrying them by cart on the roads of the 1700s was slow and expensive. Carrying them by water was cheap. Britain had a long coastline and rivers that boats could travel, and coal from the mines near Newcastle went by ship down the coast to London.

Fast streams mattered too. A stream could turn a water wheel, and a water wheel could turn machines all day. The first factories were built beside fast water, as section 05 shows.

Canals: water improved by people

Where nature had put no river, people dug one. A canal is a waterway dug by hand. The Duke of Bridgewater owned coal mines at Worsley, a few miles from Manchester. In 1759 and 1760 Parliament passed acts allowing him to build a canal. In 1761 it opened from Worsley to Stretford, on the edge of Manchester, and the price of coal in Manchester soon fell by about half. By 1765 it reached the town itself.

Other canal builders followed. Within a few decades canals linked coalfields, industrial towns and ports across England. Cheap fuel and cheap carriage drew mills to the places the water reached.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Say the job water did. Did it move goods, or turn machines? Then say what that made cheaper.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Canals are both nature and people: the water is nature's, but the canal had to be paid for, allowed by law and dug by workers.
Comparison hook
Against coal (section 01): coal was in the ground; a canal had to be built, which is why canals lead into the factors people built (sections 03 and 04).

Terms to use precisely

Canal
A waterway dug by hand, so boats can carry goods where there is no river.
Water wheel
A wheel turned by flowing water, used to power machines.
Bridgewater Canal
The canal that, from 1761, carried coal from the Duke of Bridgewater's mines at Worsley toward Manchester, reaching the town by 1765.
03

Food, People and Towns

1700s to 1801  ·  What people built

British farmers grew more food on the same land. More food fed more people, a smaller share of them farmed, and towns filled with workers and buyers.

Better farming

Farmers had long left fields empty every few years to let the soil rest. British farmers learned to plant turnips and clover instead. Turnips fed cattle and sheep through the winter, and clover made the soil richer. More animals meant more manure for the fields, and more manure meant more grain. These crops had been grown this way in Flanders first; British farmers spread them.

Landowners also fenced off the old shared village fields into private farms, often with an act of Parliament. Between 1750 and 1819 Parliament passed more than three thousand of these acts. This enclosure let a landowner farm his land the new way. It also took away the shared land that poorer villagers had used, and historians still argue about how many people it pushed off the land.

More people, fewer of them farming

More food fed more people. Britain's population grew from about 8 million in 1761 to about 10.5 million in 1801, the year of the first census. And a smaller share of those people farmed: in 1700 almost half of English working men worked on the land, and by about 1800 estimates range from about a third to about two in five.

Towns

Many of the people who did not farm lived in towns. Urbanization, the growth of towns and cities, put many workers close together, and gave them neighbors to sell to. Manchester, a town of about 23,000 people in 1773, counted 70,409 in the census of 1801.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Follow the chain. Start from a turnip and end at a town. Name each link in the chain, and the word that joins it to the next.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Urbanization is a cause here, but it is also an effect of industry, and Topic 5.9 treats it that way. Be clear which one you mean.
Comparison hook
Against laws and capital (section 04): food and towns supplied workers and buyers; laws and money decided whether anyone would risk building a mill.

Terms to use precisely

Agricultural productivity
How much food a farm grows for each field and each worker.
Enclosure
Fencing off shared village fields into private farms, often by act of Parliament.
Urbanization
The growth of towns and cities, as more people live in them.
04

Laws, Cotton and Capital

1624 to 1774  ·  What people built

Building a mill was a big risk. Laws that protected property, cotton from abroad and saved-up money made the risk worth taking, and the factors worked together.

Laws that protected property

In Britain, Parliament, where landowners and merchants sat, passed the laws that enclosed fields and allowed canals to be dug. A law of 1624 banned most monopolies but kept the patent: the crown could grant the true and first inventor the sole right to use a new invention for up to fourteen years. In 1769 Richard Arkwright patented a new spinning machine. A person who invested could expect the law to protect what he built.

The protection had limits. Arkwright's 1769 spinning patent ran out in 1783, and in 1785 a court canceled his 1775 patent on his carding and preparing machines, finding his written description of them unclear; the court also heard claims that other men had invented them.

Cotton from abroad

Cotton does not grow in Britain's climate. By the 1780s most of the cotton spun in Manchester was grown by enslaved people on plantations in the Caribbean and South America. After the 1790s more and more of it came from plantations in the United States. Britain used about 2.6 million pounds of raw cotton in 1760, almost all of it spun by hand, and about 51.6 million pounds in 1800. The factory's raw material came from far away, and most of it was grown by people who were not free. (In the 1780s a quarter or more came from the Ottoman Empire, through the port of Smyrna.)

Capital

Capital is money used to build something that makes more money. Merchants, bankers and landowners had grown rich from trade, including the Atlantic trade in enslaved people and the sugar they grew, and some were ready to risk their savings on mills and machines. Arkwright's partners, Samuel Need and Jedediah Strutt, were stocking makers who had grown rich in the hosiery trade. The partners spent thousands of pounds on machines and mills before the business made a profit, at a time when a carpenter earned no more than about £36 a year.

How the factors combined

None of these factors made an industrial revolution by itself. Watch five of them meet in one project. The Bridgewater Canal needed coal under the ground at Worsley (nature). It needed water to float the coal on (nature, improved by people). It needed acts of Parliament, passed in 1759 and 1760, to allow it to be built (law). It needed the duke's money, and he had to borrow more to pay his workmen (capital). And it needed a growing town to buy the coal (urbanization). Cheap coal then made Manchester an even better place to build mills, and the new mills made the town grow faster still.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Explain it as a process. Name the factor, add "which meant" and what it made cheaper or possible, then "so" and what it led to.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
A patent protected an invention only if the courts upheld it: a court canceled Arkwright's 1775 patent in 1785.
Comparison hook
Against coal and water (sections 01 and 02): nature's factors made things cheap in certain places; these factors decided whether people would build there.

Terms to use precisely

Patent
The sole right, given by law, to use a new invention for a fixed number of years.
Capital
Money used to build something that makes more money, such as a mill and its machines.
Raw material
What a factory makes things from, such as raw cotton for thread.
05

The Factory: One Place, One Job Each

1771 to 1835  ·  The factory system

The factors made it pay to build mills. The factory then changed work itself in two ways: it gathered production in one place, and it split the work into small, specialized jobs.

One place

In 1771, Arkwright and his partners built a cotton-spinning mill at Cromford, in Derbyshire's Derwent valley. A water wheel turned the machines. It was fed by a brook and by the Cromford Sough, a tunnel that drained the nearby lead mines; because its water came from underground, it was said never to freeze.

The mill did not send cotton out to spinners' homes. It brought the workers to the machines. Everyone came to one building, at the hours the mill set, under the eye of an overseer. The village was too small to supply enough workers, so Arkwright built houses for them. Most of his workers were women and children, some as young as seven. This was the factory system: production concentrated in a single place, around one source of power. UNESCO, which protects the valley as a World Heritage Site, says it "saw the birth of the factory system."

One job each

Inside a cotton mill, the work was split into steps. Raw cotton was cleaned, then carded (combed so its fibers lay straight), drawn out, twisted into a loose rope called roving, and spun into thread. Cromford began with machines for spinning, and in 1775 Arkwright patented machines for the earlier steps too. From then on each step after cleaning had its own machine, tended by workers who did that job and no other. This is specialization of labor.

Adam Smith, a Scottish thinker, showed why it mattered in 1776, using a small hand workshop that made pins. Ten men shared about eighteen steps, each doing only one, two, or three of them, and together they "could make among them upwards of forty-eight thousand pins in a day." A worker who had not learned the trade, working alone, he wrote, "could scarce ... make one pin in a day, and certainly could not make twenty." Because each job was small and simple, it could be learned quickly, so a mill could hire workers with no training, many of them children.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Name both changes. Where was the work done before and after? How was it divided before and after? What did that lead to?
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Smith described a small hand workshop, not a powered mill. Ask what a mill adds to his idea of splitting the work.
Comparison hook
Against the putting-out system (section 01): there, the work went to the workers' homes; here, the workers went to the work.

Terms to use precisely

Factory system
Making goods by bringing workers and machines together in one building, around one source of power.
Specialization of labor
Splitting work into steps, with each worker doing one step over and over.
Carding
Combing raw cotton so its fibers lie straight, before it is spun.

Building an Answer That Scores

Each card gathers the evidence for one part of the answer. The College Board asks how environmental factors contributed to industrialization, so the first card is the environment, the next two are what people built and how the factors combined, and the last is the factory system.

Causation

What nature gave

Evidence to sort: coal and iron close together and close to water; a shortage of wood by the 1600s; iron bought from Sweden and later Russia; coal giving England about half its energy by 1700; Darby's iron made with coke (1709); coast and rivers; fast streams and water wheels; the Bridgewater Canal (opened 1761) and the price of coal in Manchester. For each, say what it made cheaper or possible.

Causation

What people built

Evidence to sort: turnips and clover; enclosure acts; Britain's population (about 8 million in 1761, about 10.5 million in 1801); a falling share of English men farming (almost half in 1700, a third to two in five by about 1800); Manchester (about 23,000 in 1773, 70,409 in 1801); the patent law of 1624 and Arkwright's patent of 1769; cotton grown by enslaved people in the Caribbean, South America and the United States; capital from trade; Need and Strutt. For each, say how it made a mill worth building.

Causation

How the factors combined

The Bridgewater Canal needed coal, water, an act of Parliament, the duke's money and a growing town. Pick another pair of factors and show how one made the other pay off.

Change

What the factory system changed

Evidence to sort: the putting-out system; Cromford (1771), its water wheel, its houses and its workers; the steps of cotton spinning, each with its own machine; Smith's pin workshop (1776); Ure's definition (1835). Name the two changes and what they led to.

Topic 5.4

Who Made the World's Goods?

In 1750 most of the world's goods were made by hand, and most of them in Asia. Then the factory left Britain. This chapter follows how it traveled and where it took root, how the world's shares of manufacturing moved, and what the old makers kept making while their share shrank.

Go to the Topic 5.4 lesson  ·  Back to contents

How to Use This

The College Board asks you to explain how the ways goods were made, and the places they were made, changed between 1750 and 1900. That is a continuity-and-change question. Section 01 sets the starting point; sections 02 and 03 follow the change in places; section 04 measures the change; section 05 is the continuity, and why the old makers' share fell. Each section ends with a tool, a limit and a comparison you can use in an answer.

  1. 01 The world's makers in 1750: by hand, and mostly in Asia.
  2. 02 Keeping the secret, and losing it: the methods leave Britain with people.
  3. 03 Machines, money and coal: the methods reach other parts of Europe, the United States, Russia and Japan.
  4. 04 The shares move: what changed, and what a share is.
  5. 05 The old makers kept making: what continued, and why their share fell.
  6. Then the closing section, which gathers the evidence for an answer.
01

The World's Makers in 1750

About 1750  ·  The starting point

In 1750 almost everything was made by hand, at home or in workshops, and most of the world's manufactured goods were made in China and India.

Made by hand

In 1750 a shirt, a pot, a plow or a ship was made by people using hand tools, at home or in small workshops. This is hand production. Power came from muscles, animals, wind and water wheels. That was true in Britain, too: Arkwright's mill at Cromford was still twenty years away.

The places that made the most were the places with the most people and the most skilled craftworkers. India's cotton cloth, from fine thin muslins to cheap printed calicoes, was sold across the Indian Ocean, in the Middle East, in West Africa and in Europe. Chinese silk, porcelain and cotton cloth filled China's own huge markets and traveled abroad. Indian shipbuilders built ocean-going ships of teak.

Who made how much

Nobody counted every piece of cloth in the world in 1750. But the economic historian Paul Bairoch made careful estimates, working backward from what is known about people and their work. He estimated that around 1750 China made about a third of all the world's manufactured goods and India about a quarter. All of Europe together made about a quarter. Britain made under 2 percent.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Set the starting point. Before you say what changed, say how and where most goods were made in 1750.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
The 1750 figures are estimates; say "about," and use them for size, not precision.
Comparison hook
Against 1900 (section 04): in 1750 Asia made most of the world's goods; by 1900 Europe and the United States did.

Terms to use precisely

Manufacturing
Making goods, such as cloth, tools and pots, by hand or by machine.
Hand production
Making goods with hand tools, at home or in workshops, without powered machines.
Calico
A cotton cloth, often printed with colored patterns, made in India and later copied in Britain.
02

Keeping the Secret, and Losing It

1789 to 1824  ·  The methods leave Britain

Britain tried to keep its new methods at home by law. They left anyway, first in the heads of skilled people.

The laws

Britain's leaders knew the new machines were worth a great deal. British law banned skilled workers in the textile trades from leaving to work abroad, and banned the export of textile machines. The ban on workers leaving was repealed in 1824; the last bans on exporting machinery were lifted in 1843.

Samuel Slater

Samuel Slater learned the cotton trade as an apprentice at Jedediah Strutt's mill at Belper, in Derbyshire. Strutt had been Arkwright's partner, and his mills ran Arkwright's machines, so Slater learned them from the inside. In 1789 he sailed for the United States without telling anyone what he knew. At Pawtucket, Rhode Island, working with American merchants, he built water-powered spinning machines from memory. The mill that still stands there was begun in 1793 and enlarged several times afterward.

John Cockerill

In Belgium, John Cockerill, the son of an English machine maker, began building machines at Seraing, near Liège, in 1817, and added ironworks there in the 1820s. Liège sat on one of the richest coalfields on the continent of Europe, with rivers to carry goods. The pattern from Topic 5.3, coal near water, was waiting there.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Name the carrier. Say who or what carried the methods to a new place.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
One person is a case, not the whole spread: Slater shows how the methods could travel, not how fast they spread everywhere.
Comparison hook
Against section 03: here the methods traveled in people's heads, past the bans; machines and money carried them too, more and more after the bans ended.

Terms to use precisely

Skilled workers
People trained to build, run or mend machines or to do a craft well.
Apprentice
A young worker who learns a trade by working for a master for several years.
03

Machines, Money and Coal

1820s to 1900  ·  Other parts of Europe, the US, Russia, Japan

Machines and money carried the methods too, and most took root near coal, or by rivers that could turn wheels: in other parts of Europe, in the United States, and later in Russia and Japan.

Other parts of Europe

The first steam railway in the German states, from Nuremberg to Fürth, opened in 1835 with a locomotive built in England. On the continent, factories grew where coal lay, as they had in Britain: around Liège in Belgium, in the Ruhr valley of the German states, and in northern France.

The United States

In the United States, wealthy Boston merchants paid for big cotton mills at Lowell, Massachusetts, from the 1820s, beside a river that could turn their wheels. Most of the workers were young women from New England farms. By 1900 the United States made more of the world's manufactured goods than any other country.

Russia and Japan

Russia and Japan came later, mostly after 1870. A Welsh engineer, John Hughes, built ironworks in the coal country of the southern Russian Empire, in what is today eastern Ukraine, in the early 1870s; the town that grew up around them was named Yuzovka, after him (today Donetsk). In Japan the Osaka Spinning Company opened in 1883 with cotton-spinning machines made in Britain, driven by steam power, and it ran day and night.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Find the pattern. List three places, say what carried the methods to each, then say what they share.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
The pattern is about carriers and resources; it does not mean every place with coal industrialized.
Comparison hook
Against Britain (Topic 5.3): Britain built the methods first from its own factors; the later regions borrowed the methods and added their own coal, water and money.

Terms to use precisely

Steam power
Power from an engine that burns fuel, usually coal, to boil water and turn the steam into motion.
Locomotive
A steam engine on wheels that pulls a railway train.
04

The Shares Move

1750 to 1900  ·  What changed

Steam-powered factories made goods far faster and more cheaply than hands could, so the regions that had them made a fast-growing share of the world's goods, and the share made in Asia fell.

What changed

A share is a part of a whole. In Bairoch's estimates, Britain's share of the world's manufacturing went from under 2 percent in 1750 to about a fifth by 1860. By 1900 Europe and the United States together made more than four-fifths of the world's manufactured goods, and the United States had passed Britain as the largest maker.

Over the same years, China's share fell from about a third to about 6 percent, and India's from about a quarter to under 2 percent.

A share is not an amount

Imagine a pizza that grows much bigger. Your slice can stay the same size while your share of the pizza shrinks. The world was making far more goods in 1900 than in 1750. So a region's share can fall even while it keeps making goods, because the total grows faster. For India, though, Bairoch's estimates suggest it also made less per person over time: it lost ground, not only share.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Use two numbers. Give a share for 1750 and a share for 1900, and say "estimated."
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Shares say nothing by themselves about whether people were better or worse off.
Comparison hook
Against section 05: the share is the change; the weavers and shipbuilders are the continuity.

Terms to use precisely

Share
A part of a whole; here, the part of all the world's manufactured goods made in one region.
Estimate
A careful guess built from the evidence that exists, not an exact count.
05

The Old Makers Kept Making

1750 to 1900  ·  What continued, and why the share fell

India, China and the Middle East kept making cloth, ships and other goods, much of it by hand. Their share shrank because the rest of the world made far more, because machine-made goods were cheaper, and because of the trade rules of the people in power, among other causes historians still argue about.

What continued

In India, hand weaving shrank, but it did not die. Weavers kept working cloth on handlooms, and many switched to cheaper machine-spun thread so they could keep weaving. The economic historian Tirthankar Roy finds that handloom cloth held a roughly steady share of India's cloth market from the 1890s to the 1930s, and in 1908, in one province of northern India alone, about a million people still lived from handloom weaving. In China, farm families kept weaving cloth at home, more and more of it from cheaper machine-made thread. In the Ottoman Empire, the number of handlooms in the Syrian cities of Aleppo and Damascus held steady from 1860 to 1914.

Indian shipbuilders kept building, too. At the Bombay dockyard, the shipyard of the city now called Mumbai, the Wadia family of master shipbuilders built teak warships for Britain's own Royal Navy. One of them, HMS Trincomalee, launched in 1817, is still afloat today in Hartlepool, England, where its museum calls it Britain's oldest warship still afloat.

Why the share fell

One reason the share fell is that the rest of the world made far more goods. Another is that the old makers lost buyers. Cloth from Lancashire's machines was cheaper than cloth woven by hand, even in India itself. In 1815 India sold about £1.3 million worth of cotton cloth abroad and bought only about £26,000 worth from England. By 1832 it sold less than £100,000 worth and bought more than £400,000 worth. From about 1830, India bought more cotton cloth than it sold. India, which had sold cloth to the world, now bought British cloth, and it sold raw cotton to British mills.

Power mattered too. Much of India was ruled by the British East India Company, and British cotton cloth entered India at a tax of only 2½ percent. Earlier, Britain had taxed Indian cloth heavily: around 1813, Indian calicoes paid taxes of about 70 to 85 percent of their value to be sold in Britain. Historians still argue about how much each cause mattered: cheaper machine-made goods, the trade rules of the people in power, and, in India, troubles that had begun before the factories did, such as the breakup of the Mughal Empire and years of drought.

The Middle East felt the same pressure. In 1838 English cotton cloth sold in Egypt for less than cloth from Egypt's own new mills. (Who built those mills, and why, is Topic 5.6.)

Shipbuilding followed the same path. Bombay's teak ships were among the best wooden ships of their day. But by the middle of the 1800s navies were turning to ships of iron, driven by steam, and they came mostly from British shipyards and engine works. Bombay's age of teak warships came to an end.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Name the continuity with the change. Say what kept being made, and say what happened to its share.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Weavers who kept weaving are evidence of continuity, not of comfort: many were poorer than before, and Bairoch estimated that India's output per person fell.
Comparison hook
Against Britain in 1750 (section 01): then Britain bought India's cloth; by about 1830 India bought more of Britain's cloth than it sold.

Terms to use precisely

Handloom
A loom worked by hand and foot, with no engine.
Raw cotton
Cotton as it is picked, not yet spun into thread or woven into cloth.
Dockyard
A shipyard where ships are built and repaired.

Building an Answer That Scores

Each card gathers the evidence for one part of the answer. The College Board asks how modes and locations of production changed over time, so the cards are the starting point, the change in places, the change in shares, and the continuity.

Continuity and Change

The starting point

Evidence to sort: hand production at home and in workshops; Bairoch's estimates for about 1750 (China about a third, India about a quarter, Europe about a quarter, Britain under 2 percent); India's cloth sold across Asia, Africa and Europe; Indian teak ships.

Making Connections

Where the methods went, and what carried them

Evidence to sort: the British laws (to 1824 and 1843); Slater at Pawtucket (1789 to 1793); Cockerill at Seraing (1817); the Nuremberg to Fürth railway (1835); Lowell (from the 1820s); Hughes at Yuzovka (1870s); the Osaka Spinning Company (1883). For three of them, name the carrier, then say the pattern.

Continuity and Change

What changed

Evidence to sort: Bairoch's estimates for 1860 and 1900 (Britain about a fifth by 1860; Europe and the United States over four-fifths by 1900; China about 6 percent, India under 2); steam-powered factories; cheaper machine-made cloth; India's cloth trade turning around by about 1830; the 2½ percent tax on British cloth entering India.

Continuity and Change

What continued

Evidence to sort: India's hand weaving, shrinking but surviving (about a million people living from it in one province in 1908); machine-spun thread on hand looms; Chinese farm families weaving at home; the handlooms of Aleppo and Damascus; the Bombay Dockyard and HMS Trincomalee (1817). For one, say what continued and what happened to its share.

Topic 5.5

More Power, Longer Reach

In 1750 almost all the energy used in the world came from muscles, wood, wind and water. By 1900 about half of it came from coal. This chapter follows how machines unlocked that buried energy, what new things it let people make, and how railroads, steamships and the telegraph carried goods, people and news into the interiors of continents.

Go to the Topic 5.5 lesson  ·  Back to contents

How to Use This

The College Board asks you to explain how technology shaped economic production between 1750 and 1900. That is a causation question, and the answer is a chain: each technology made the next one possible. Section 01 sets the starting point; sections 02 and 03 are the power; section 04 is the new methods; section 05 is the reach, and its two effects, trade and migration. Each section ends with a tool, a limit and a comparison you can use in an answer.

  1. 01 Energy before 1750: muscles, wood, wind and water, and their limits.
  2. 02 The steam engine: from a mine pump to the power of factories.
  3. 03 More coal, then oil: how much more energy, and a second engine.
  4. 04 The second industrial revolution: steel, chemicals, electricity and precision machinery.
  5. 05 Longer reach: railroads, steamships and the telegraph, and more trade and migration.
  6. Then the closing section, which gathers the evidence for an answer.
01

Energy Before 1750

About 1750  ·  The starting point

In 1750 almost all the energy used in the world came from things that grow, and from wind and water. Each had a limit.

Things that grow, blow and flow

In 1750 a farmer plowed with a horse or an ox, a family cooked and kept warm with wood, a ship crossed the ocean by sail, and a mill turned beside a river. Food gave energy to the muscles of people and animals. Wood gave fire. Wind and water turned some machines. All of these came, in the end, from the sun and the land: crops and forests had to grow, every year, to be used.

Each had a limit you could see. A horse gets tired and must be fed from land that could grow food for people. A forest takes decades to grow back. A sailing ship waits for the wind. A water wheel works only where a stream flows strongly, and turns slowly when the water runs low. Topic 5.3's example, Arkwright's mill at Cromford, ran on a water wheel fed by a brook and a mine drain.

Energy buried underground

There was another store of energy, underground. Coal and oil are each a fossil fuel: the remains of plants and tiny sea creatures, buried for millions of years, with energy stored inside them. Coal did not need land to grow this year. Britain already burned a great deal of it for heat (Topic 5.3). The trick was to turn its heat into motion.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Set the starting point. Before you say how technology changed production, say what powered it before.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Water wheels and windmills were good machines; the limit was the energy itself, not the skill of the people who used them.
Comparison hook
Against 1900 (section 03): in 1750 energy came mostly from things that grow; by about 1900 coal gave about half of the world's energy.

Terms to use precisely

Fossil fuel
A fuel such as coal or oil, formed from plants and sea creatures buried for millions of years.
Water wheel
A wheel turned by flowing water, used to drive machines in a mill.
Biomass
Fuel from things that grow, such as wood, straw and dung.
02

The Steam Engine

1712 to the 1780s  ·  From a pump to a power

The steam engine began as a pump for flooded coal mines. Watt made it use far less coal and turn wheels, so factories could run on coal instead of rivers.

A pump for mines

As British miners dug deeper for coal, water flooded the mines. In 1712 Thomas Newcomen set up a steam engine near Dudley Castle, in the English Midlands, to pump it out. A fire boiled water into steam. The steam filled a cylinder under a piston; a spray of cold water turned the steam back into water, the air pressed the piston down, and a great wooden beam rocked to work the pump. It worked, but it burned a great deal of coal, because the cylinder was cooled and heated again on every stroke.

Watt's improvement

James Watt, an instrument maker at the University of Glasgow, was repairing a model Newcomen engine when he saw the waste. In 1765 he found the fix: cool the steam in a separate chamber, the separate condenser, so the cylinder could stay hot. He patented the idea in 1769. Watt's engines used less than a third of the coal of a Newcomen engine.

Then came the change that mattered most for factories. Watt's business partner, Matthew Boulton, wanted engines that could drive mill machinery. In the 1780s Boulton and Watt built engines that turned a wheel. A wheel can drive spinning machines, looms and hammers. A mill no longer had to sit beside a fast river: it could run on coal, wherever coal could be brought, and cotton mills crowded into towns such as Manchester.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Explain a process step by step. The problem, what the machine did, what it made possible, what followed.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
A patent is not the same as a change in production: Watt's engines spread over decades, and water wheels stayed common.
Comparison hook
Against section 01: the water wheel tied a mill to a river; the rotary steam engine tied it to coal, which could be carried.

Terms to use precisely

Steam engine
A machine that uses steam from boiling water, heated by burning fuel, to make motion.
Separate condenser
Watt's chamber for cooling steam outside the cylinder, so the cylinder stays hot and less coal is burned.
Rotary motion
Turning in a circle, like a wheel, so an engine can drive machines.
03

More Coal, Then Oil

1854 to 1900  ·  The fossil fuels revolution

Machines let people use far more energy than ever before: coal gave about half the world's energy by 1900. Oil and the internal combustion engine came next, but their big effects came later.

How much more energy

Steam engines needed coal, and coal mines needed steam engines to pump them dry, so each made the other grow. Britain mined about 65 million tons of coal in 1854 and about 225 million tons in 1900. By about 1900, coal supplied about half of all the energy used in the whole world; things that grow, such as wood, gave about the other half. The College Board calls this the fossil fuels revolution: it "greatly increased the energy available to human societies."

A person who lived through it said so. In 1865 the British economist William Stanley Jevons wrote that "with coal almost any feat is possible or easy; without it we are thrown back into the laborious poverty of early times." He was worried that Britain's cheap coal would not last forever. (His words are this lesson's Primary Source.)

Oil, and an engine that burns fuel inside itself

In 1859 Edwin Drake drilled a well at Titusville, Pennsylvania, and struck oil. For the rest of the 1800s, most oil was refined into kerosene, a fuel for lamps.

A steam engine burns its fuel under a boiler, outside the engine. An internal combustion engine burns its fuel inside the engine itself, in the cylinder. In 1876 Nikolaus Otto built a four-stroke gas engine in Germany, and in 1886 Carl Benz patented a car driven by a small engine that burned a fuel made from oil.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Say how much. Use one number to show that the energy available grew greatly.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Coal caught up with wood and other things that grow only around 1900, and passed them after; say "about half" by 1900, not that coal had replaced wood.
Comparison hook
Against the steam engine (section 02): the internal combustion engine was developed before 1900, but most of its effects came after.

Terms to use precisely

Fossil fuels revolution
The great increase in energy that came when machines let people use coal and oil.
Kerosene
A fuel made from oil, burned in lamps.
Internal combustion engine
An engine that burns its fuel inside the cylinder, like a car engine.
04

The Second Industrial Revolution

1850 to 1900  ·  Four new methods

After 1850, with so much energy to use, new methods made steel cheap, made chemicals in factories, sold electric power, and cut machine parts precisely enough to swap.

Steel

Steel is iron with a small, carefully measured amount of carbon. It is stronger and tougher than ordinary iron, but before the 1850s it was slow and costly to make in large amounts. In 1856 Henry Bessemer showed that blowing air through melted iron burned out the carbon and other impurities, and the burning kept the metal hot. The United States made about 69,000 tons of steel in 1870 and about 10 million tons in 1900; Britain went from about 215,000 tons to about 4.9 million. Steel became rails, bridges, ships and machines.

Chemicals

In 1856 an eighteen-year-old London chemistry student, William Perkin, made a purple dye, mauve, from chemicals that came from coal tar, a sticky leftover of coal. It was the first synthetic dye to sell well. German chemical companies such as BASF, founded in 1865, built laboratories whose job was to invent new dyes, and in 1897 BASF began selling indigo blue made in a factory instead of from a plant. By 1914 Germany made most of the world's dyes.

Electricity

In 1882 Thomas Edison's Pearl Street Station in New York began selling electric power, lighting about 400 lamps on its first day. Electric motors could let each machine run on its own motor, instead of on belts from one big steam engine. But the change was slow: in 1899, electric motors gave less than 5 percent of the power in American factories, and it took about two more decades for them to give half. Factories had to be rebuilt to use them well.

Precision machinery

Machine tools, such as lathes and milling machines, had begun to cut metal parts to exact sizes, so that one part fit any copy of the same machine; after 1850 the method spread widely. These are interchangeable parts. Standard screw threads, set early by Joseph Whitworth in Britain in 1841 and then by William Sellers in the United States in 1864, helped machines with interchangeable parts, "from typewriters to locomotives," as the American Society of Mechanical Engineers puts it, spread.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Name the method and what it made. Steel made rails and ships; dyes came from coal tar; motors could drive single machines; precise tools made parts that fit.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
A new method is not the same as a change everywhere: electricity, especially, spread slowly.
Comparison hook
Against section 03: the second industrial revolution ran on the energy of the first; coal ran the furnaces that made steel and gave the tar that made dyes.

Terms to use precisely

Second industrial revolution
The new methods in steel, chemicals, electricity and precision machinery after about 1850.
Steel
Iron with a small, measured amount of carbon, stronger and tougher than ordinary iron.
Interchangeable parts
Machine parts made so exactly that any one fits any copy of the same machine.
05

Longer Reach

1830 to 1904  ·  Railroads, steamships and the telegraph

Railroads, steamships and the telegraph reached the interiors of continents and joined distant markets, which led to more trade and more migration.

Railroads

Before railroads, heavy goods moved cheaply only by water, so the middle of a continent, far from rivers and the sea, was hard to reach. The Liverpool and Manchester Railway, opened in England in 1830, was the world's first railway between two cities, with trains pulled by steam locomotives. Railways spread fast: Russia had 27 kilometers of railway in 1840 and more than 53,000 in 1900; Germany went from 469 kilometers in 1840 to more than 51,000 in 1900.

India's first passenger train ran from Bombay to Thane in 1853. The first railroad across the United States was finished at Promontory Summit, Utah, in 1869. Russia began the Trans-Siberian Railway in 1891, and by 1904 trains could cross to the Pacific Ocean. A railroad could reach farms, mines and towns where no river or canal went.

Steamships

Under sail, emigrants from Norway took about 53 days on average for the whole trip to America. By steamship, the Atlantic crossing from England took about 12 days in the 1860s, and the fastest ships of the 1870s crossed in about 7 or 8 days. The Suez Canal, opened in Egypt in 1869, cut the voyage from Europe to Asia; it was of little use to sailing ships, because the winds of the Red Sea were hard to sail against, so it mostly served steamships. Steamboats also pushed up rivers into the interior of continents: in 1854 the steamer Pleiad went far up the Niger and Benue rivers in West Africa, and none of its crew died, because they took quinine, a medicine against malaria. What European empires did with this reach is Unit 6.

The telegraph

A telegraph sends messages as pulses of electricity along a wire. In 1844 Samuel Morse sent "What hath God wrought?" from Washington to Baltimore. A cable under the Atlantic worked only a few weeks in 1858; from 1866 cables carried messages across it without a lasting break, and in 1870 another undersea cable, through the Red Sea, reached Bombay. A message that once traveled as fast as a ship could now travel in minutes, so merchants could know prices in distant markets within a day.

More trade, more migration

Cheaper, faster transport and fast news joined markets. In 1870 wheat cost 57.6 percent more in Liverpool, England, than in Chicago. By 1913 the gap was only 15.6 percent. Wheat grown in the middle of North America, carried by train to the coast and by steamship across the ocean, fed workers in Britain.

Trains and ships carried people, too. Migration means people moving to live in a new place. About 55 million Europeans moved to the Americas and Australia between 1850 and 1914. Between 1846 and 1940, more than 29 million Indians and more than 19 million Chinese moved to Southeast Asia and the lands around the Indian Ocean, and tens of millions of Chinese and Russians moved into Manchuria, Siberia and Central Asia. Steamships and railways made these journeys faster and cheaper. Why people moved, and what they found, is Unit 6.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Trace the cause to the effect. Say what the technology made possible, then name the trade or the migration it led to, with a number.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Technology made journeys cheaper and faster; it does not explain on its own why people chose to move, which is Unit 6's question.
Comparison hook
Against section 01: in 1750 heavy goods moved cheaply only by water, and news only as fast as a horse or a ship.

Terms to use precisely

Interior
The middle of a continent, far from the sea.
Telegraph
A way of sending messages as pulses of electricity along a wire.
Migration
People moving to live in a new place.

Building an Answer That Scores

Each card gathers the evidence for one link of the chain. The College Board asks how technology shaped economic production over time, so the cards follow the causes in order: power, new methods, reach, and its effects.

Causation

Machines unlock fossil fuels

Evidence to sort: energy from muscles, wood, wind and water before 1750; Newcomen's mine pump (1712); Watt's separate condenser (1765, patented 1769), using under a third of the coal; rotary engines (1780s) and mills in towns; Drake's oil well (1859); Otto (1876) and Benz (1886).

Developments and Processes

How much more energy

Evidence to sort: Britain's coal, about 65 million tons (1854) and about 225 million (1900); coal about half the world's energy by about 1900; Jevons (1865): "with coal almost any feat is possible or easy"; 8,000 cars in the United States in 1900.

Developments and Processes

New methods after 1850

Evidence to sort: the Bessemer process (1856) and US steel (about 69,000 tons in 1870, about 10 million in 1900); Perkin's mauve (1856), BASF (1865) and factory indigo (1897); Pearl Street (1882) and motors under 5 percent of US factory power (1899); interchangeable parts and standard screw threads (1841, 1864).

Causation

Longer reach, more trade and migration

Evidence to sort: the Liverpool and Manchester Railway (1830); Russia's railways (27 km in 1840, over 53,000 in 1900); Promontory Summit (1869); the Trans-Siberian (1891 to 1904); sail from Norway about 53 days, steam from England about 12 (1860s), the fastest 7 or 8 (1870s); Suez (1869); the Pleiad (1854); Morse (1844), the Atlantic cable (1866), Bombay (1870); the wheat price gap (57.6 percent in 1870, 15.6 in 1913); 55 million Europeans (1850 to 1914); over 29 million Indians and 19 million Chinese (1846 to 1940). For one, explain the link from the technology to the effect.

Topic 5.6

Industry on Purpose

In Britain and the United States, private owners built the first factories. A few governments did not wait. This chapter follows two of them, Egypt under Muhammad Ali and Japan in the Meiji era: why each government built industry itself, how it paid for it, and why Japan's industry lasted while most of Egypt's factories closed.

Go to the Topic 5.6 lesson  ·  Back to contents

How to Use This

The College Board asks you to explain the causes and effects of the economic strategies of different states. That is a causation question, and it comes with a comparison: two states, the same strategy, different results. Section 01 says why any government would build industry; sections 02 and 03 follow Egypt; sections 04 and 05 follow Japan. Build a chain for each with the same four links, the threat, the decision, the strategy and the result, then use the closing section to compare them.

  1. 01 Why a state builds: the exception, and the fear behind it.
  2. 02 Egypt's strategy: a governor, a cotton monopoly, state mills and an army.
  3. 03 Egypt's result: it worked, then it stopped, and why.
  4. 04 Japan's reforms: Perry, the unequal treaties, and a new government.
  5. 05 Japan builds, then sells: railways and mills, the 1880 sale, and regional power.
  6. Then the closing section, which gathers the evidence for an answer.
01

Why a State Builds Factories

The early 1800s  ·  The exception

Most early factories were built by private owners. A small number of governments built industry themselves, wanting armies to match stronger powers.

The rule, and the exception

In Britain, Richard Arkwright and his partners paid for the mill at Cromford (Topic 5.3). In the United States, Boston merchants paid for the big cotton mills at Lowell (Topic 5.4). Governments helped in other ways, with patents, roads and taxes on foreign goods, but private owners built and owned the factories.

A small number of governments did something different. They planned factories, paid for them, owned them and protected them. This is state-sponsored industry, and the College Board names it as the exception: "a small number of states and governments promoted their own state-sponsored visions of industrialization."

The fear behind it

By the early 1800s the countries with factories, steam engines and new weapons were becoming the strongest in the world. A ruler watching them could see two dangers: a country without industry could be beaten in war, or forced to sign treaties it did not want. Waiting for merchants to build factories might take too long. So a few rulers decided to build industry themselves, to make their states strong.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Start with the cause. Before you describe what a government built, say what it was afraid of.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
"A small number" is the College Board's phrase: state-built industry was the exception, not how industry usually began.
Comparison hook
Against Topics 5.3 and 5.4: there, private owners built the first factories; here, governments did.

Terms to use precisely

State-sponsored industry
Industry that a government plans, pays for and protects.
Private owner
A person or company, not the government, that owns a business.
02

Egypt's Strategy

1805 to the 1830s  ·  Muhammad Ali

Muhammad Ali, Egypt's Ottoman governor, used the state's control of farming and cotton to pay for factories, and the factories supplied his army.

A governor who wanted power of his own

In 1798 a French army under Napoleon invaded Egypt and easily defeated its rulers, the Mamluks, a class of soldier-lords. The French left in 1801. Among the Ottoman troops sent to take Egypt back was Muhammad Ali, an officer from an Albanian family. In 1805 the Ottomans named him governor of Egypt, and by 1811, after his men killed the Mamluk leaders in the Cairo Citadel, he ruled alone.

Egypt was a province of the Ottoman Empire, and Muhammad Ali was the sultan's governor. Napoleon's victory had shown what a modern European army could do. Muhammad Ali wanted Egypt strong enough that he, and his family after him, could hold it, even against the sultan. Strength meant an army, and an army needed guns, uniforms and ships.

Crops paid for factories

His government took control of Egypt's farming. It told peasants what crops to plant, bought the crops at low prices, and sold them abroad at higher ones. When there is only one allowed buyer or seller, that is a monopoly. A new crop, long-staple cotton, first grown for sale in 1820, earned a great deal of money.

With that money, from the late 1810s, the government built factories: cotton mills, and works for weapons, sugar and other goods. It bought machines in Europe and hired European experts to run them. By the early 1830s about 30 cotton mills employed about 30,000 workers, many of them making cloth and uniforms for the army. To protect the mills, Muhammad Ali kept cheap British cloth out of Egypt.

Drafted workers, drafted soldiers

The workers did not choose these jobs. They were drafted, the way Egyptian peasants had long been made to dig canals and repair dams. From 1822 peasants were drafted into the army too. Forcing people to serve in the army is conscription. The army reached about 130,000 soldiers by the early 1830s. The historian Khaled Fahmy writes that Muhammad Ali's schools, factories and hospitals "were all founded to serve it." In the 1820s Muhammad Ali also sent Egyptian students to Europe to learn its sciences.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Follow the money. Say who paid for the factories (peasants, through the cotton monopoly) and what the factories were for (the army).
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Muhammad Ali was an Ottoman governor building power for his family, not an Egyptian nationalist building a nation: his court's official language was Ottoman Turkish.
Comparison hook
Against Japan (section 05): both governments made farmers pay; Egypt through a monopoly on crops, Japan through a land tax.

Terms to use precisely

Monopoly
Control of a trade by one buyer or seller, here the government.
Conscription
Forcing people to serve in the army.
Long-staple cotton
Cotton with long fibers, which makes strong, fine thread.
03

Egypt's Result

1831 to the 1840s  ·  It worked, then it stopped

The army won wars until European powers stopped it. Then, with the army cut, the monopolies ended, almost no coal and drafted workers, most of the factories failed.

It worked

For a while the strategy did what Muhammad Ali wanted. In 1831 his army, led by his son Ibrahim, invaded Syria, and it beat the sultan's own armies more than once.

Then it stopped

Britain, Austria, Russia and Prussia did not want a strong Egypt breaking the Ottoman Empire apart. In 1840 they sided with the sultan, and British warships and Ottoman troops drove Ibrahim out of Syria. In 1841 the sultan made the governorship of Egypt hereditary in Muhammad Ali's family, passing to its eldest male, but Egypt had to give up its conquests except Sudan. The sultan's decree said: "In time of peace, 18,000 men will suffice." Egypt also had to accept a trade treaty that Britain had signed with the Ottoman sultan in 1838, which ended Muhammad Ali's monopolies and opened Egypt to cheap foreign goods.

The factories had problems of their own, too. Egypt had almost no coal, so many machines were turned by animals instead of steam engines. The drafted workers resisted the work, and the managers had little experience. By the mid-1840s, about a decade after their peak in the early 1830s, most of the new factories had failed. Egypt went on growing more and more cotton, almost all of it sold abroad, much of it to the mills of Britain. What that led to is Unit 6.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Weigh the causes. Name at least one cause from outside Egypt and one from inside, and say which you think mattered most.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Do not say Britain alone destroyed Egypt's industry: Japan also had to accept low taxes on foreign goods, and its industry grew.
Comparison hook
Against Japan (section 05): Japan's industry lasted; most of Egypt's did not.

Terms to use precisely

Hereditary
Passed down from parent to child.
Treaty
A written agreement between states.
04

Japan's Reforms

1853 to 1873  ·  Outside pressure, inside reform

American and European warships and unequal treaties pushed Japan's new Meiji government to reform the country before it built industry.

Ships and treaties

In 1853 an American naval officer, Commodore Matthew Perry, sailed warships into Edo Bay, near today's Tokyo, and demanded that Japan open its ports to trade. Japan had no navy that could stop him. Treaties in 1854 and 1858 opened Japanese ports to Americans and Europeans, let foreigners accused of crimes in Japan be tried in their own countries' courts, and took away Japan's control over its own trade. A tariff agreement of 1866 held Japan's taxes on most imports to about 5 percent, and Japan did not win back full control of them until 1911. A treaty forced on a weaker country that gives the stronger side rights it does not give back is an unequal treaty.

A new government

Some samurai blamed the shogun, the military ruler who governed Japan in the emperor's name, for giving in. In 1868 a group of young samurai overthrew him and governed in the name of the fifteen-year-old emperor, Meiji. This is the Meiji Restoration. In April 1868 the new government issued the Charter Oath, which promised: "Knowledge shall be sought throughout the world so as to strengthen the foundations of imperial rule." The government's slogan was "Rich country, strong army."

Reform first

The Meiji leaders changed Japan itself. In 1871 they abolished the domains of the old lords and made one central state. The samurai lost their privileges, and men of every class were drafted into a national army. A national school system began in 1872. A new land tax, paid in money instead of rice, gave the government money to spend. From 1871 to 1873 a group of leaders, the Iwakura Mission, toured the United States and Europe to study how they worked.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Link outside pressure to inside reform. Name the pressure (Perry, the unequal treaties), then one reform, then how that reform helped Japan build industry.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Japan did not "just copy the West": its leaders chose what to learn, and their stated aim was to strengthen imperial rule.
Comparison hook
Against Egypt (section 02): Egypt's strategy was one governor's project; Japan changed its whole society first.

Terms to use precisely

Unequal treaty
A treaty forced on a weaker country that gives the stronger side rights it does not give back.
Meiji Restoration
The 1868 overthrow of the shogun by samurai who governed in the name of the emperor, Meiji.
Shogun
The military ruler who governed Japan in the emperor's name until 1868.
05

Japan Builds, Then Sells

1872 to 1895  ·  From state industry to regional power

Japan's government built railways, mills and shipyards, then sold most of them to private companies, and the strength it built made Japan a regional power.

The state builds

The government built Japan's first railway, from Tokyo to Yokohama, which opened in 1872 with British engineers. In the same year it opened the Tomioka Silk Mill, with French machines and a French engineer, Paul Brunat, to teach Japanese workers, mostly young women, to reel silk by machine, so the method could spread to other mills. It built telegraph lines, shipyards, mines, and factories for weapons and for goods such as cement, glass and cloth.

Farmers paid for much of this through the land tax. Some samurai rebelled against losing their place, and in 1877 the new army of drafted commoners crushed the last great revolt.

Then the state sells

Running so many businesses cost more than the government could afford. In 1880 it decided to sell most of them to private investors. Business families such as Mitsui and Mitsubishi bought them and grew into huge business groups called zaibatsu: Mitsubishi bought the Nagasaki shipyard in 1887, and Mitsui took over the Miike coal mine, the country's largest, in 1889. Private companies such as the Osaka Spinning Company (Topic 5.4) built more. The state started key industries; private companies carried them on and built much more.

A regional power

To win back its own courts, Japan rewrote its laws on French and German models, and in July 1894 Britain agreed to end the foreign courts in Japan from 1899, so that foreigners there would be tried by Japanese law, and other countries followed; Japan won back full control of its tariffs only in 1911. Weeks later, in 1894 and 1895, Japan fought China over Korea and won. In the Treaty of Shimonoseki, China gave up its claim over Korea, gave the island of Taiwan to Japan, and agreed to pay an indemnity of 200 million taels of silver (a tael is a Chinese measure of silver). Within a week, Russia, Germany and France demanded that Japan give back one more piece of land it had won, and Japan gave in, which angered Japan's leaders. Japan, forced to open its ports forty years before, was now a regional power, with a colony of its own. What empires did with that power is Unit 6.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Finish the chain. Say what the state built, who carried it on after 1880, and one piece of evidence that Japan became a regional power.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Industry was one reason Japan grew strong; its reforms and its new army were others.
Comparison hook
Against Egypt (section 03): Egypt's army was cut and its mills mostly closed; Japan's industry passed to private companies and kept growing.

Terms to use precisely

Zaibatsu
A huge Japanese family business group that owned many companies.
Regional power
A state strong enough to win wars and gain land in its own part of the world.
Indemnity
Money a defeated country is made to pay the winner.

Building an Answer That Scores

Each card gathers the evidence for one part of the answer. The College Board asks for the causes and effects of the economic strategies of different states, and its skill for this topic is finding a pattern, so the cards give each state's chain and then compare them.

Causation

Egypt's chain

Evidence to sort: Napoleon's invasion (1798); Muhammad Ali governor (1805), ruling alone by 1811, aiming to hold Egypt for his family; the cotton monopoly and long-staple cotton (1820); about 30 state cotton mills and 30,000 drafted workers by the early 1830s; conscription from 1822, an army of about 130,000; Syria invaded (1831); driven out (1840); the army cut to 18,000 and the 1838 treaty accepted (1841); almost no coal; most mills failed within about a decade.

Causation

Japan's chain

Evidence to sort: Perry's warships (1853); the treaties of 1854 and 1858; the Meiji Restoration and the Charter Oath (1868); "Rich country, strong army"; domains abolished (1871); conscription, schools (1872), the land tax; the Iwakura Mission (1871 to 1873); the Tokyo to Yokohama railway and the Tomioka Silk Mill (1872); the 1880 decision to sell; Mitsui and Mitsubishi; the end of the foreign courts (agreed 1894, in force 1899); victory over China and Taiwan (1895).

Making Connections

The pattern

Evidence to sort into "both," "Egypt only" and "Japan only": an army to match stronger powers; state money for the first factories; a cotton monopoly; a land tax paid in money; European machines and experts; students sent to Europe in the 1820s; the Iwakura Mission (1871 to 1873); drafted mill workers; a national school system; an Ottoman province. Then write your own pattern sentence.

Making Connections

The difference

Evidence to weigh: Egypt's army cut to 18,000 in 1841 and its monopolies ended; almost no coal in Egypt, many machines turned by animals; drafted workers and inexperienced managers; Japan never conquered, though forced into unequal treaties; Japan's reforms of 1871 to 1873; the Miike mine; the 1880 sale to Mitsui and Mitsubishi; Japan's 5 percent tariffs from 1866. Choose the reason you think mattered most, and say why.

Topic 5.7

Freer Trade, Bigger Business

Factories made more goods than ever. Between 1750 and 1900, three things changed around them: the rules of trade, the shape of business, and the goods people could buy. This chapter follows all three, and in each one asks what changed, what carried on, and how one change relates to another.

Go to the Topic 5.7 lesson  ·  Back to contents

How to Use This

The College Board asks you to explain how economic systems, ideas and institutions developed between 1750 and 1900, and how they contributed to change. That is a continuity and change question, and its skill asks you to connect one development to another. Sections 01 and 02 follow the rules of trade; sections 03 and 04 follow business; section 05 follows the goods people could buy. For each, write a before, an after and one thing that carried on, then use the closing section to connect them.

  1. 01 The old rules: mercantilism, and Adam Smith's argument against it.
  2. 02 Britain chooses free trade: the Corn Laws, 1846, and who followed.
  3. 03 New tools for business: limited liability, stock markets and banks.
  4. 04 Businesses across borders: HSBC, Lever's soap and the Dutch margarine makers.
  5. 05 Cheaper goods, for some: what people could buy, and who gained.
  6. Then the closing section, which gathers the evidence for an answer.
01

The Old Rules and a New Argument

Around 1750 to 1776  ·  Mercantilism and Adam Smith

Under mercantilism, governments controlled trade with tariffs, bans and monopolies. In 1776 Adam Smith argued that a country, like a sensible family, should buy what others make more cheaply.

Trade as a contest

In Topic 4.5 you met mercantilism, the idea that a kingdom grew strong by selling more to other countries than it bought from them, and by keeping its colonies' trade for itself. Governments acted on it. They put tariffs, taxes on imported goods, on foreign products; they banned some goods completely; and they gave chartered companies the sole right to trade in a region. Britain's East India Company held the sole right to carry on British trade with India and China.

To a mercantilist, trade was a contest. If another country sold more to you than it bought, it was winning and you were losing.

The tailor and the shoemaker

In 1776 Adam Smith, a Scottish thinker who had been a professor at Glasgow, published An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations. You met the book's pin workshop in Topic 5.3. Much of the rest of it is an attack on what Smith called "the mercantile system."

Smith started from an ordinary household. "It is the maxim of every prudent master of a family, never to attempt to make at home what it will cost him more to make than to buy. The tailor does not attempt to make his own shoes, but buys them of the shoemaker." What is sensible for a family, he went on, "can scarce be folly in that of a great kingdom. If a foreign country can supply us with a commodity cheaper than we ourselves can make it, better buy it of them ..."

Tariffs and bans, Smith argued, made ordinary buyers pay more so that a few producers could profit. "Consumption is the sole end and purpose of all production," he wrote, but "in the mercantile system, the interest of the consumer is almost constantly sacrificed to that of the producer."

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Start with the before. Name one way governments controlled trade around 1750, then name Smith's argument against it.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Smith's book did not change the rules by itself. The rules changed decades later, and for more than one reason (section 02).
Comparison hook
Against Topic 5.3: there, Smith's pins showed specialization inside a workshop; here, the same idea is applied to whole countries.

Terms to use precisely

Mercantilism
The idea that a country grows strong by selling more than it buys and controlling its trade.
Tariff
A tax on goods brought in from another country.
Laissez-faire
A French phrase, roughly "let them do it": the idea that government should let people trade freely.
02

Britain Chooses Free Trade

1815 to 1879  ·  The Corn Laws and after

Britain repealed its Corn Laws in 1846 and ended its tariffs on factory goods by 1860, partly persuaded by Smith's ideas. Much of Western Europe followed in the 1860s, but not every country, and not for good.

Bread and rents

Britain's Corn Laws kept cheap foreign grain out of the country ("corn" meant grain). A law of 1815 banned foreign wheat until British prices rose very high, to 80 shillings a quarter (a quarter is a measure of grain); from 1828 a tariff on imported grain, highest when British prices were low, took the ban's place. The laws kept grain prices high, which kept the rents of Britain's landowners high, and landowners filled Parliament.

In 1838 factory owners and merchants in Manchester started a campaign that became the Anti-Corn Law League, led by Richard Cobden and John Bright. It held meetings, printed pamphlets and raised money across the country. Cheap bread, its speakers said, would help workers; and countries that sold their grain to Britain would have money to buy British cloth.

Not every worker trusted them. Many Chartists, members of the workers' movement for the vote, argued that high prices meant high wages, so to them the manufacturers' cry of "cheap bread" really meant cheap labor: lower wages.

Famine and repeal

In 1845 a disease destroyed much of Ireland's potato crop, and famine began. Prime Minister Robert Peel, who had once defended the Corn Laws, decided they had to go. His bill cut the tariff on grain step by step until February 1849, leaving only a small duty after that. In 1846 Parliament passed it, but most of Peel's own party voted against him, and the party split.

Britain kept going. By 1860 it had ended its tariffs on imported factory goods, keeping a few taxes, such as those on tea, sugar and wine, mainly to raise money. Britain had become a free trade country.

Others follow, for a while

In 1860 Britain and France signed the Cobden-Chevalier Treaty, cutting tariffs on each other's goods. In the 1860s a chain of similar treaties lowered tariffs across much of Western Europe.

Then some countries turned back. From 1879 Germany put tariffs back on imported grain and iron, to protect its farmers and its factories after cheap grain from America drove prices down. The United States raised its tariffs on factory goods in 1861, just before the Civil War began, raised them again during the war, and kept them high to the end of the century. Britain stayed with free trade.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Give the change, and its limits. Name the change, and one country where tariffs stayed high or came back.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
"Began abandoning" is the College Board's phrase: free trade spread, then partly retreated.
Comparison hook
Against section 01: Smith's argument came in 1776; Britain's rules changed in 1846 and 1860. Ideas took decades to become laws.

Terms to use precisely

Free trade
A policy of letting goods cross a country's borders without heavy tariffs.
Repeal
To cancel a law.
Protection
Using tariffs to shield a country's own producers from foreign competition.
03

New Tools for Business

1720 to the 1880s  ·  Limited liability, stock markets, banks

Industry needed more money than a family had. Limited liability, stock markets and banks let many people invest in one business, with less to lose.

The old way

Companies that sold shares were not new. The Dutch East India Company (VOC) sold shares in 1602 (Topic 4.5), and people bought and sold them in Amsterdam. But from 1720 to 1825, forming such a company in Britain usually took special permission from the government: a royal charter or an act of Parliament. Most businesses belonged to one family or a few partners, as Richard Arkwright's mill at Cromford did (Topic 5.3). If a partnership failed, each partner could lose his house and savings to pay its debts.

Limited liability

A railway or a steamship line cost more than any few partners could pay. A law of 1855 let companies formed by ordinary investors limit what their owners could lose to the money they had put in, not everything they owned, and a law of 1856 let almost any group of seven or more people in Britain register such a company. This is limited liability. France passed similar laws in 1863 and 1867. With less to lose, many more people with modest savings could invest.

Stock markets and banks

A stock market, or stock exchange, is where people buy and sell shares. An investor who needed money back could sell shares to someone else, without waiting for the company to close. London had had a stock exchange since the 1700s. In a railway boom in the mid-1840s, crowds of British investors rushed to buy railway shares, and many lost their savings when prices fell. An American print from 1886, "The World's Exchanges," shows the exchanges and trading halls of eight cities, from New York and Chicago to London, Paris, Berlin, Hamburg, Frankfurt and Brussels.

Banks did the rest. They lent money to companies, changed one country's money into another's, and paid bills between ports thousands of miles apart.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Connect a tool to growth. Say how one tool worked (less risk, or an easy way to sell) and what it made possible (more people investing in one company).
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Selling shares was old; what changed was who could form a company, and how little an owner could lose.
Comparison hook
Against Topic 5.6: there, the governments of Egypt and Japan paid for many early factories; here, many private investors do.

Terms to use precisely

Share
A part of a company that a person can own and sell.
Limited liability
A rule that owners of a company can lose only the money they put in.
Stock market
A place where people buy and sell shares.
04

Businesses Across Borders

1860s to 1929  ·  HSBC, Lever, Unilever

As trade and production stretched around the world, some businesses grew to work in many countries at once, relying on banking and finance to do it.

A bank for trade with China

The bank known today as HSBC opened in Hong Kong in March 1865, as the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Company; in 1866 it became the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation. It was started by Thomas Sutherland, a Scot who worked there for a shipping company, with a committee of merchant firms, to give local businesses better banking for their trade. It opened in Shanghai a month later and in London that July, to change money for clients in China and India. By 1900 it worked in 16 countries and territories.

One of the firms on its first committee, Dent and Company, had grown rich trading opium into China, a trade Britain had forced China to accept by war. How that happened is Unit 6.

Soap and margarine

In England, William Lever began selling Sunlight Soap in 1884, made with oils from tropical plants such as coconut and palm kernels. By 1886 he had registered the Sunlight name in the United States, and from 1888 he built a factory town for his workers, Port Sunlight. In 1890 the business became a limited company, Lever Brothers, Limited, and from 1894 it sold shares to the public. In the Netherlands, the Jurgens and Van den Bergh families of Oss turned butter trading into margarine factories and sold across the North Sea to England.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Use the Key Concept's own links. Global trade "contributed to" big transnational businesses, which "relied on" banking and finance: show both links with one business.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Not every business crossed borders: most were still small and local.
Comparison hook
Against section 03: HSBC was a transnational business that itself offered banking services, loans and the changing of money, to other traders.

Terms to use precisely

Transnational business
A company that works in more than one country.
Brand
A name a company puts on its product so buyers know and ask for it.
05

Cheaper Goods, for Some

1780s to 1900  ·  Consumer goods and living standards

Better factory methods made goods more available, more affordable and more varied, and living standards rose, much faster after about 1860, for some people and not for others.

More, cheaper, more kinds

Around 1750, cotton thread was still spun by hand, one thread at a time. Once machines spun it (Topic 5.3), its price fell fast: by 1815 even the coarsest cotton yarn cost about a third of its early 1780s price, even after taking rising prices into account. Factories kept improving how they made things. The economic historian Knick Harley found that the price of cotton cloth "fell impressively" while machines spun the yarn, and "continued to fall thereafter as technology improved in weaving and finishing." Soap that grocers had once cut from long bars came in wrapped bars with a brand name, like Sunlight, advertised to every household. Ships and railways (Topic 5.5) brought fruit, tea and wheat from far away to city markets.

Who gained

A family's standard of living is how well it lives: what it can afford to eat, wear and buy. In Britain, one careful estimate finds that working families' standard of living rose by less than 15 percent from the 1780s to the 1850s; most historians agree it grew much faster from about 1860 to 1900.

Not everyone gained from this new economy, and not everyone accepted it. Workers organized, reformers pushed for new laws, and some thinkers imagined a different system. That is Topic 5.8.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Use all three words. The College Board says goods became more available, more affordable and more varied: give an example of one.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
"For some" is the College Board's phrase: say who gained and who did not.
Comparison hook
Against section 02: free trade made imported food cheaper; here, factories made their own goods cheaper.

Terms to use precisely

Standard of living
How well a family lives: what it can afford to eat, wear and buy.
Real wages
What pay can actually buy, once prices are counted.
Consumer goods
Things people buy for themselves and their homes.

Building an Answer That Scores

Each card gathers the evidence for one part of the answer. The College Board asks how economic systems, ideas and institutions developed and contributed to change, and its skill for this topic is connecting one development to another, so the cards give each row's before and after, and then the connections.

Continuity and Change

Trade

Evidence to sort into "before," "after" and "carried on": mercantilism, tariffs, bans and monopolies; Smith's Wealth of Nations (1776); the Corn Laws (1815); the Manchester campaign (1838); the Irish famine (1845); repeal (1846); tariffs on factory goods ended by 1860; the Cobden-Chevalier Treaty (1860) and the treaties of the 1860s; Germany's tariffs from 1879; America's high tariffs.

Continuity and Change

Business and goods

Evidence to sort: the VOC's shares (1602); the government's permission needed from 1720 to 1825; family partnerships; limited liability (laws of 1855 and 1856); France's laws (1863 and 1867); the railway share boom (mid-1840s); "The World's Exchanges" (1886); HSBC (1865); Sunlight Soap (1884), its U.S. trademark (1886), Port Sunlight (1888); Unilever (1929); cheaper cotton cloth; wrapped, branded soap; living standards rising little to the 1850s and faster after about 1860.

Making Connections

How one change relates to another

Pairs to explain: free trade and global trade; global trade and HSBC; limited liability and big companies; stock markets and railway building; better factory methods and cheaper cloth; cheaper goods and living standards. For each pair, say whether one caused the other, made it possible, or answered it, with a detail for each side.

Continuity and Change

For some

Evidence to weigh: Feinstein's estimate (under 15 percent from the 1780s to the 1850s); real wages rising faster from about 1860; height and infant deaths up to 1900; city poverty (Topic 5.9); the people who grew cotton, palm oil and tea (Unit 6); Chartists who said "cheap bread" really meant cheap labor. Decide who gained most, and say why.

Topic 5.8

Calls for Change

Industry made some people rich and left many working long hours for little pay, and it made a few countries strong enough to push the rest around. This chapter follows the people who called for change, why they called, and what their calls changed, from Manchester's streets to the courts of Istanbul and Beijing.

Go to the Topic 5.8 lesson  ·  Back to contents

How to Use This

The College Board asks you to explain the causes and effects of calls for change in industrial societies from 1750 to 1900. That is a causation question, and its skill asks you to source a source: who made it, why, for whom, and in what situation. Each section below gives a cause, the people who called for change, and what happened.

  1. 01 The pressure: one city, two descriptions, and why they differ.
  2. 02 Workers organize: unions, the Chartists, and workers' parties.
  3. 03 Thinkers imagine: socialism, Marx, and communism.
  4. 04 Reformers and governments: four kinds of reform, and Bismarck.
  5. 05 The old empires: the Ottoman Empire and Qing China modernize, and meet resistance.
  6. Then the closing section, which gathers the evidence for an answer.
01

One City, Two Descriptions

1845 to 1853  ·  Manchester

Industrial capitalism made some people rich and left many working long hours for low pay in crowded towns. Two descriptions of Manchester show both, and show how a source's maker shapes what it says.

Engels in Manchester

Friedrich Engels was a young German whose father was a partner in a cotton business with a mill near Manchester. He was sent to England to learn the business. In 1845 he published a book, in German, for readers in Germany: The Condition of the Working Class in England in 1844. It describes the streets where Manchester's mill workers lived.

In the English translation of 1887, Engels describes the river Irk as "a narrow, coal-black, foul-smelling stream, full of debris and refuse." He also noticed how the town was built: "a person may live in it for years, and go in and out daily without coming into contact with a working people's quarter or even with workers, that is, so long as he confines himself to his business or to pleasure walks."

The directory's Manchester

A directory was a book listing a town's businesses and their addresses. One of Manchester and Salford, printed by Whellan and Company (the copy that can be read today is dated 1853), opens with a chapter called "Sketches of Manchester and its Vicinity." It describes "the innumerable large mills and factories whose tall chimneys shoot up in every direction," which "betoken the activity, enterprise, and wealth of its inhabitants," and it calls the town "the 'workshop of the world'."

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Start with the pressure. Name one thing industry did to workers' lives, and say who described it, and why.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Manchester's conditions are Topic 5.9's subject. Here they are the cause; the calls for change are this topic.
Comparison hook
Against Topic 5.7: there, living standards rose "for some." Here are the people who were not among the some.

Terms to use precisely

Point of view
Who made a source, and where they stood.
Purpose
Why a source was made.
Audience
Who a source was made for.
02

Workers Organize

1799 to 1906  ·  Britain, Germany, the United States

Workers organized for better conditions, shorter hours, higher wages and a voice in government. In Britain, unions went from a crime to a legal standing; in Britain and Germany, workers built political parties.

From a crime to a right

A single worker who asked for more pay could be fired. Workers together could strike, stopping work until the employer gave way. That is what a labor union is for. In Britain, the Combination Acts of 1799 and 1800 made it illegal for workers to combine to demand higher wages or shorter hours. Parliament repealed them in 1824; a law of 1825 then limited what unions could lawfully do.

In 1834 six farm laborers from Tolpuddle, in Dorset, were sentenced to seven years' transportation to Australia for swearing a secret oath when they formed a union. A mass protest followed, with a petition of about 800,000 names, and in 1836 they were pardoned.

Skilled workers built lasting unions for their trades. In June 1868 unions met in Manchester as the first Trades Union Congress. The Trade Union Act of 1871 said that a union's purposes were not unlawful just because they were "in restraint of trade," which gave unions legal standing. After years of campaigning, a law of 1847 limited women and young people in textile mills to ten hours of work a day from 1848.

The Charter

Workers also wanted a voice in making the laws. In 1838 the Chartists published a People's Charter with six points: a vote for every man over 21, a secret ballot, no property requirement for members of Parliament, pay for members, districts of equal size, and a new Parliament elected every year. Over 1.2 million people signed their first petition in 1839, and the Chartists claimed over three million for the second in 1842. Parliament rejected both, and a third in 1848.

The Chartists lost every petition, but five of their six points later became law, one only roughly: the property requirement went in 1858, the vote reached many working men in 1867 and 1884 and every man over 21 in 1918, the secret ballot came in 1872, districts were redrawn closer to equal size in 1885, and members were paid from 1911. A new Parliament every year never came.

Parties in different countries

In Germany, Ferdinand Lassalle founded a workers' party in 1863, and August Bebel and Wilhelm Liebknecht founded another in 1869. They united in 1875. Chancellor Otto von Bismarck banned socialist meetings and newspapers in 1878; in February 1890, while it was still banned, the party won more votes than any other, about 20 percent; the law lapsed that September, and in October the party renamed itself the Social Democratic Party.

In Britain, unions and socialists founded the Labour Representation Committee in February 1900 to elect working men to Parliament; in 1906 it won 29 seats and took the name Labour Party. In the United States, the American Federation of Labor, founded in December 1886 with Samuel Gompers as president, joined unions of skilled workers who wanted higher wages, shorter hours and better conditions.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Give a cause and an effect. Name one thing workers wanted, how they organized for it, and what they won or failed to win.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Workers' parties wanted more than wages. Many wanted "alternative visions of society," as the College Board says, which is section 03.
Comparison hook
Britain and Germany: in both, workers built parties, but Germany's government banned its socialists for twelve years.

Terms to use precisely

Labor union
A group of workers who bargain with their employer together.
Strike
When workers stop work together until their demands are met.
Chartists
A British workers' movement, from 1838, that demanded the vote for every man.
03

Imagining a Different Society

1800 to 1891  ·  Owen, Marx and Engels

Discontent with who held power encouraged new ideas. Socialists wanted the means of making wealth owned in common; Marx predicted that workers would overthrow the owners and build a classless society he called communism.

Owen and socialism

Robert Owen took over the management of the New Lanark cotton mills in Scotland in 1800. He shortened working hours and opened a school for the workers' children in 1816. In 1825 he bought land at New Harmony, Indiana, for a community where people would share their work and its rewards; it broke up within two years.

In the late 1820s, Owen's followers began to call their ideas socialism: the idea that land, factories and the other things a society uses to make wealth should be owned and run in common, for everyone, and not by private owners for their own profit.

The Manifesto

In 1847 a small group of radicals in London, the Communist League, asked Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels to set out its ideas. Their Manifesto of the Communist Party was printed in German in London in February 1848. The English translation of 1888, which Engels checked, begins its first section: "The history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles."

Industry, Marx argued, was splitting society "into two great hostile camps": the bourgeoisie, who owned the factories, and the proletarians, wage workers who owned nothing but their ability to work. The workers would one day overthrow the owners, end private ownership of the means of production ("the theory of the Communists may be summed up in the single sentence: Abolition of private property"), and build a society without classes: communism. The Manifesto ends: "The proletarians have nothing to lose but their chains. They have a world to win. Working Men of All Countries, Unite!" (The German original reads "Proletarians of all countries, unite!"; "Workers of the world, unite!" is a later, popular English version.)

What the ideas did by 1900

No revolution like the one Marx predicted won lasting power in an industrial country before 1900. The Paris Commune of 1871, which Marx praised as a workers' government, was crushed within about ten weeks. His ideas spread through parties instead. In 1891 Germany's Social Democrats adopted a program, drafted mainly by Karl Kautsky, based on Marx's ideas, while they kept winning seats in elections. In July 1889 socialist parties from many countries met in Paris and called for workers everywhere to march on May 1, 1890, for an eight-hour working day.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Name the cause exactly. "Discontent with established power structures": who held power, and why were socialists angry about it?
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Marx was one of "various" thinkers, as the College Board says, and his revolution did not come before 1900.
Comparison hook
Owen tried to build a better society by example; Marx predicted that workers would take it by revolution.

Terms to use precisely

Socialism
The idea that the means of making wealth should be owned and run in common.
Communism
Marx's classless society, with no private ownership of the means of production, to be won by workers' revolution.
Proletarians
Marx's word for wage workers.
04

Reformers and Governments

1833 to 1889  ·  Britain and Germany

Governments, organizations and individuals pushed political, social, educational and urban reforms. Some reforms answered workers; Bismarck's were also a weapon against their party.

Four kinds of reform

A reform changes a law or a system to fix a problem without overthrowing it. The College Board names four kinds, and Britain had all of them.

Political. After the Reform League, a workers' organization, held huge meetings in London's Hyde Park in 1866 and 1867, the Reform Act of 1867 added about 938,000 voters, many of them working men in towns, and the act of 1884 brought in many voters in the countryside. No woman could vote in a British national election until 1918.

Social. The Factory Act of 1833 banned children under nine from most textile mills (silk mills were left out), limited children of nine to thirteen to nine hours a day, and appointed four inspectors. The Mines Act of 1842, brought in by Lord Ashley, a member of Parliament, after a government inquiry into children's work in mines, stopped all women and girls, and boys under ten, from working inside mines.

Educational. The Education Act of 1870, written by William Forster, a government minister, after a campaign by the National Education League, set up elected school boards to provide elementary schools where church schools fell short, and let them require attendance; a law of 1880 made every local authority require it.

Urban. In the hot summer of 1858 the River Thames, which carried London's sewage, smelled so foul it was called the "Great Stink." London's engineer Joseph Bazalgette then built 82 miles of large brick sewers, fed by about 1,100 miles of street sewers, to carry the waste away; the work was completed in 1875. The crisis in the cities is Topic 5.9's story.

A government reforms to beat its critics

Germany's government reformed for another reason. Bismarck banned the socialists in 1878. Then a message from the emperor in 1881 promised to cure social ills "not only through the repression of Social Democratic excesses" but also by "the consistent and positive promotion of workers' welfare." The Reichstag passed health insurance in 1883, accident insurance in 1884, and insurance for old age and disability in 1889.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Sort the reforms. Name one reform of each kind, and say whether a government, an organization or individuals pushed it.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Reforms fixed problems without overthrowing anything. Socialists said that was not enough; Bismarck hoped it would be.
Comparison hook
Britain and Germany both reformed; Germany's government reformed partly to defeat the socialists it had banned.

Terms to use precisely

Reform
A change to a law or system to fix a problem without overthrowing it.
Factory Act
A British law limiting who could work in factories, and for how long.
Social insurance
Government-run payments to workers who are sick, injured or old.
05

The Old Empires Modernize, and Meet Resistance

1789 to 1898  ·  Istanbul and Beijing

For the Ottoman Empire and Qing China, the pressure came from stronger outside powers, more and more of them industrial. Both governments tried to modernize their armies and economies, and both met resistance from inside.

The Ottoman Empire

After a lost war with Russia (1787 to 1792), Sultan Selim III built a new infantry in the 1790s, the "New Order," with European-style uniforms, imported guns and French instructors. The Janissaries, the old army corps, saw it as a threat, and important conservative religious scholars sided with them. A revolt overthrew Selim in 1807. In June 1826 Sultan Mahmud II destroyed the Janissaries and built a new army along European lines.

On 3 November 1839, at Gülhane in Istanbul, the government announced the Tanzimat ("reorganization"). Its decree promised "perfect security for life, honor, and property," "a regular system of assessing taxes" and a regular system of military service, and it said that "the Muslim and non-Muslim subjects of our lofty Sultanate shall, without exception, enjoy our imperial concessions." Mahmud II's government had opened a state fez factory in Istanbul in the 1830s; around 1850 it was fitted with steam engines and machines from Britain and Belgium. The state added an ironworks in 1843 and telegraph lines from 1855.

A decree of 1856 promised equal treatment to Christians and Jews. Many Muslims, who had long held a higher place than Christians and Jews, resented losing it; some Christian church leaders were unhappy too. In December 1876 the empire got a constitution and a parliament. In February 1878 Sultan Abdulhamid II suspended the constitution and dissolved the parliament.

Qing China

Britain defeated China in the Opium War of 1839 to 1842, and Britain and France defeated it again from 1856 to 1860 (Unit 6), while the Taiping Rebellion tore through the country until 1864. In 1861 Prince Gong set up an office for foreign affairs, and officials such as Zeng Guofan, Li Hongzhang and Zuo Zongtang began what was called Self-Strengthening: learning Western ways of making weapons and ships while keeping China's own system of rule. They built the Jiangnan Arsenal in Shanghai (1865), a navy yard at Fuzhou (1866) and a steamship company (1872).

In 1862 the court opened the Tongwen Guan in Beijing to train translators. In early 1867 Prince Gong asked the court to add astronomy and mathematics, taught partly by Western teachers, and to invite young degree-holders from the civil service examinations to study there. "Western learning is something urgently in need of study," his memorial said. Woren, a senior scholar and the emperor's tutor, objected: "establishing a country rests on valuing propriety and righteousness, not on schemes and stratagems." The court backed the prince, and the plan went ahead, but of about 98 who applied, only about 30 were admitted, and few were the well-educated young officials the plan had hoped for.

In 1894 and 1895 Japan defeated China's new navy. In June 1898 the young Guangxu Emperor declared that reform was national policy and issued decree after decree. In September the Empress Dowager Cixi and officials who opposed the reforms seized power, confined the emperor, and executed six reformers.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Same pattern, different cause. Name the outside pressure, one reform, and one person or group who resisted.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Neither empire "refused to change." Both tried; the question is how far reform went, and who stopped it.
Comparison hook
Against Topic 5.6: Egypt and Japan built industry from the top too. Japan's reforms went furthest, and in 1895 Japan defeated China.

Terms to use precisely

Tanzimat
Ottoman reforms from 1839 to 1876; the word means "reorganization."
Janissaries
The Ottoman Empire's old army corps, destroyed in 1826.
Self-Strengthening
Qing reforms from the 1860s that borrowed Western weapons and machines.

Building an Answer That Scores

Each card gathers the evidence for one part of the answer. The College Board asks for the causes and effects of calls for change, so each card gives a cause, the call, and its effects, and the last asks you to source a source.

Causation

Workers

Cause: long hours, low pay, no vote, and laws against combining. Calls: unions (1824 on), the Chartists (1838 to 1848), the Social Democrats (1875, 1890), the Labour Party (1900, 1906), the American Federation of Labor (1886). Effects: unions' legal standing (1871), the ten-hour law (1847), the vote for many working men (1867, 1884); the Charter's petitions refused.

Causation

Thinkers

Cause: "discontent with established power structures." Calls: Owen's socialism (late 1820s), the Communist Manifesto (1848), Capital (1867). Effects: the Social Democrats' Marxist program (1891), the May Day marches (1890); no revolution in an industrial country by 1900.

Causation

Reformers, governments and old empires

Reforms: political (1867, 1884), social (1833, 1842), educational (1870, 1880), urban (London's sewers after 1858); Bismarck's insurance (1883, 1884, 1889) to win workers from the socialists. The old empires: outside pressure (the Opium Wars; Japan's victory, 1895); reforms (the Tanzimat from 1839; Self-Strengthening from the 1860s); resistance (the Janissaries, 1807; Muslims who resented 1856; Abdulhamid, 1878; Woren, 1867; Cixi, 1898).

Sourcing and Situation

Source a source

Pick Engels, the Manchester directory, the Manifesto, Bismarck's speech or Woren's memorial. Say who made it, why, for whom and when, and how that shapes what it says.

Topic 5.9

A City Built for a Quarter of Itself

Manchester grew twelvefold in two generations, into pipes, drains and streets laid out for a market town. This chapter is what that was like to live in: the two classes industrialization created and what separated them at the dinner table rather than in theory, why the same century sent one woman to a mill at five in the morning and told another that leaving the house was improper, and why the water killed people.

Go to the Topic 5.9 lesson  ·  Back to contents

How to Use This

Section 01 is the two classes as lived positions rather than as the categories Topic 5.6 argues about. Section 02 answers the question the success criteria press hardest, why the same ideology produced opposite lives in different classes. Sections 03 and 04 are the city and the water, which is where three of the named challenges get their explanation.

  1. 01 Two classes: what actually separated a clerk from a spinner, and why the middle class was new.
  2. 02 Separate spheres: an ideology you had to be able to afford.
  3. 03 The city: why unplanned growth produces housing shortage, filth and crime as arithmetic.
  4. 04 The water: cholera, typhoid, and the mechanism that made a crowded city lethal.
  5. Then the closing section, which turns all of it into comparison sentences you can write.
01

What Actually Separated Them

c. 1800 to 1900  ·  Middle and working

The Topic 5.6 chapter defines the two classes by their relationship to capital, which is correct and abstract. Lived from the inside, the line was drawn by something simpler: whether your income was predictable, and whether you could stop working without your household collapsing within a fortnight.

The middle class, and why it was new

The middle class ran from factory owners, merchants and bankers at the top through engineers, doctors, lawyers, managers, shopkeepers and, at the bottom edge, clerks and schoolteachers. What united a range that wide was the source of the income: business, qualification and salary rather than an inherited title or rents from land.

That is genuinely new and it is the point the success criteria want. In the societies of every earlier unit, the people at the top held their position by birth and by land, and status was largely fixed at birth. A cotton manufacturer richer than a duke, or a physician with no land at all and a professional income, did not fit that scheme, and the nineteenth century is partly the story of this class acquiring the political weight to match its money, which is what the Reform Act of 1832 in Topic 5.6 concedes.

Its markers were visible and deliberate: a house away from the works and eventually in a suburb reachable by railway, at least one domestic servant as the minimum sign of respectability, a parlor for receiving visitors, schooling for the children, church attendance, and a wife who did not earn. That last one is section 02, and it is the sharpest marker of all.

And a warning about the phrase. Middle class in nineteenth-century Britain does not mean the middle of the income distribution, which would be a well-paid manual worker. It means a position defined by the source of income and by a set of respectability markers, and a clerk earning less than a skilled engineer would count himself in it and the engineer out of it, which tells you the category is social as much as economic.

The working class, and what insecurity means

The working class sold labor for wages, in mills, mines, workshops, docks, building sites and, for the largest single group of women, other people's houses. The Topic 5.3 chapter has the hours and the danger; what belongs here is what the wage did and did not buy.

Insecurity is the defining feature, more than the level of the wage. Work was seasonal, trade was cyclical, and a downturn such as those of the 1840s put whole towns out of work at once. An injury ended earnings immediately, and the machine that caused it carried no liability. There was no sick pay and no pension, and after 1834 public relief was meant to run through the workhouse of Topic 5.6, deliberately made worse than the worst job. In practice most paupers went on being relieved in their own homes, because refusing outdoor relief to everyone would have cost more than the parishes could raise in a bad year, so what the New Poor Law reliably delivered was not the workhouse itself but the threat of it. So a household that was comfortable in a good year was destitute within weeks of a bad one, and this is why so much working-class organizing, described in Topic 5.8, went into friendly societies, burial clubs and mutual insurance rather than into politics.

Household economy followed from that. A working-class family needed multiple earners, which is why women and children worked, and the household budget went overwhelmingly on food, above all bread, with rent next, leaving nothing to absorb a shock. Diet was monotonous and often adulterated, since bread was bulked with alum and other additives before food regulation. Everyone in a family shared one or two rooms, and possessions could go to the pawnshop on Monday and be redeemed on payday.

And the class was internally graded in ways contemporaries took very seriously. A skilled engineer, printer or mule spinner in steady work, with a union and a friendly society, lived a life closer to a clerk's than to a casual dock laborer's, and that stratum, sometimes called the labor aristocracy, is where the unions of Topic 5.8 were built.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Security as the real class line. The mechanism is that a predictable income lets a household plan, save, insure and educate its children, while a household whose earnings stop the day the work stops must spend everything on food and rent and can be destitute within a fortnight, so the difference that shapes daily life is less the size of the income than whether it survives a bad month.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Both classes were internally graded, and a clerk on a small salary and a skilled spinner on a good wage lived similarly while placing themselves on opposite sides of the line, which is why respectability markers mattered so much.
Comparison hook
Against the casta system in Topic 4.7: that hierarchy assigned position by ancestry recorded at baptism, and this one by income and occupation, in principle changeable. In practice the markers of respectability, dress, housing, accent, a wife who did not work, policed the boundary nearly as effectively, which is worth saying rather than treating openness as achieved.

Terms to use precisely

Middle class
The class whose income came from business, qualification or salary rather than inherited title or land.
Working class
The class living on wages, defined in daily life less by the level of the wage than by its insecurity.
Respectability
The visible markers, servant, parlor, schooling, a non-earning wife, by which middle-class status was claimed and policed.
Friendly society
A mutual insurance club for sickness, burial and unemployment, the working-class answer to an economy with no safety net.
Labor aristocracy
The skilled, steadily employed workers whose conditions and organization set them apart within the working class.
02

An Ideology You Had to Be Able to Afford

c. 1820 to 1900  ·  Gender by class

The nineteenth century held, loudly, that a woman’s place was the home. The same century employed enormous numbers of women in mills, mines and other people’s kitchens. Both are true because the doctrine described the lives of households that could afford it and was used to judge the households that could not.

What the doctrine said, and what it required

Separate spheres held that men and women were suited by nature to different domains: the man to the public world of work, commerce and politics, the woman to the private world of household, children and moral guardianship. The home was described as a refuge from a competitive commercial world, and the woman was its keeper, which gave her genuine authority over household management, spending, the servants and the children's early education while removing her from anything outside the door.

Now the economics, which is what the success criteria are asking for when they demand the why. This arrangement requires a household that can live on one income. That is the whole explanation. A family that can survive on a man's earnings can withdraw a woman's from the market, and doing so becomes the visible proof that it can, which converts a non-earning wife into the single most legible marker of middle-class status. It is expensive, and being expensive is the point.

A working-class household could not afford it. It needed every earner, so women worked in textile mills, in workshops and the sweated trades, in agriculture at harvest, underground in mines until the ban of 1842, and above all in domestic service, which was the largest single occupation for women in Britain across the century. Married women often withdrew from full-time factory work when children arrived and took in laundry, lodgers, sewing or childminding instead, which is invisible in the census and was real income.

So the same ideology produced opposite lives, and produced a judgment on top of that. Working-class women were criticized for neglecting a domestic role their household economy made impossible, and the criticism came from reformers, clergy and inspectors who often sincerely wanted to help. Naming that double bind is a strong move in an essay: the doctrine did not merely fail to describe working-class life, it supplied the vocabulary in which working-class life was found wanting.

What it cost, and what it built

The costs to middle-class women were concrete. Girls' education emphasized accomplishments, music, drawing, French, over the classics and mathematics that qualified a boy for university and a profession. Professions were closed: medicine, law, the church, the universities, and admission came only late in the century and against organized resistance. Under coverture, described in Topic 5.1, a married woman's property and earnings were her husband's until the Acts of 1870 and 1882. Economic dependence was total, which made a bad marriage inescapable, since divorce was practically unavailable and custody went to fathers.

And what it built, which the flat version of this story leaves out. Domestic authority was real authority, over a household budget and a staff. Philanthropy, charity visiting, Sunday schools and moral reform were defined as extensions of the domestic sphere and were therefore permitted, and they took middle-class women into slums, workhouses and prisons, gave them organizational experience, and produced the campaigning networks that the Topic 5.8 chapter's temperance and abolition movements ran on. The WCTU's slogan of home protection is exactly this move: accept the sphere and argue that protecting the home requires acting outside it. That is how a doctrine of confinement generated a generation of organizers.

Children divide the same way and for the same reason. Middle-class childhood became a protected stage with schooling, toys and sentiment attached to it, which is affordable when a child does not need to earn. Working-class children worked, in mills and mines as Topic 5.3 describes, and then in street trades, workshops and domestic help, and their earnings were a necessary part of the household budget rather than pocket money. The compulsory schooling of Topic 5.8 changed that by making it illegal, which cost poor families income and was resented for that reason before it was welcomed.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Separate spheres as a status purchase. The mechanism is that withdrawing a woman’s earnings from a household is only possible above a certain income, so a non-earning wife becomes visible proof that a family has reached it, which turns a claim about female nature into a marker of class position and explains why the doctrine was asserted most loudly by the people who could just barely afford it.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
It was an ideal rather than a description even among the middle class, since widows, unmarried women and the wives of struggling shopkeepers worked, and much of that work was concealed precisely because the ideal existed.
Comparison hook
Against colonial honor in Topic 4.7: there a family’s standing was located in the sexual conduct of its women, and here in the fact that its women did not work, and in both cases a household’s public position is measured by the constraint it can impose on the women in it. Two centuries apart, and the same instrument.

Terms to use precisely

Separate spheres
The doctrine assigning men the public world and women the domestic, describable only in households that could live on one income.
Domestic service
The largest single occupation for women in nineteenth-century Britain, and the labor that made middle-class domesticity possible.
Cult of domesticity
The elevation of the home as a moral refuge and of the woman as its guardian, and a claim to social status.
Home protection
The argument that defending the home requires acting outside it, which took women from domesticity into organized politics.
Protected childhood
The middle-class idea of childhood as a stage for schooling and play, affordable only where a child need not earn.
03

The Arithmetic of an Unplanned City

c. 1800 to 1875  ·  Housing, filth, crime

The problems of the industrial city were not caused by the character of the people in it, which is what contemporaries mostly said. They were caused by a rate of growth that no existing infrastructure or government could absorb, and each named challenge follows from that arithmetic.

The numbers, and what they make impossible

Manchester went from roughly 25,000 to about 300,000 between 1772 and 1850; Britain passed from a majority rural to a majority urban population across the same century, the first country in history to do so. Migration came from the countryside, pushed by enclosure and by agricultural change and pulled by wages, and from Ireland in enormous numbers after the famine of the 1840s.

Now take the challenges the success criteria name and derive each one, which is what they are asking for.

Housing shortage. Population grew far faster than dwellings could be built, so rents rose, and what got built was built to the cheapest specification the market would bear, since there were no building regulations to set a floor. Hence back-to-backs, houses sharing three walls with neighbors so that only one side has windows and no through ventilation is possible; hence courts and cellars, with families living below street level in rooms that flooded; hence overcrowding measured in families per room rather than rooms per family. Overcrowding is not a preference, it is what happens when the number of people divided by the number of rooms produces that answer.

Insufficient infrastructure. A town of 25,000 has pipes, drains, wells and streets sized for 25,000. Multiply the population by twelve and there is no mechanism by which the pipes multiply too, because water was supplied by private companies to customers who could pay, drainage was a parish matter, and the municipal government was a corporation designed for a market town, in some cases with no authority to levy for such works at all. The reformed municipal corporations from 1835 and the public health legislation from 1848 are the beginning of building a government capable of the problem, and they arrive decades after the problem.

Pollution and filth. The coal smoke is in Topic 5.5. On the ground it was human and animal waste: privies shared by dozens of households, cesspools under floors, middens in courts, horse dung in the streets in enormous daily volumes, slaughterhouses and tanneries among the dwellings, and no collection service. This is the immediate setting for section 04.

Crime, and how to handle the claim. Recorded crime rose, and so did the number of things counted as crime, the number of police counting them, and the population being counted, so the statistics are measuring several changes at once. What is solid is that a city of strangers works differently from a village where everyone is known, since anonymity weakens informal control, and that a population with no savings and no relief but the workhouse will produce theft in a downturn. The response was institutional: the Metropolitan Police from 1829 and forces elsewhere after, plus prisons built on new principles. Contemporaries mostly read urban crime as moral degeneration among the poor, and that reading is itself evidence about the observers, which is the sort of distinction worth drawing in an essay.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Growth outrunning institutions. The mechanism is that housing, water, drainage, policing and government are built to the scale of an existing population and can only be extended by decisions someone has the authority and money to make, so a city that multiplies in a generation is by definition short of all of them at once, and the shortfall appears as overcrowding, filth, disease and disorder regardless of the character of the people arriving.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Speed explains the shortfall and not its distribution. Who lived in the cellars and who moved to a suburb was decided by income and by whose interests the local corporation served, so the crisis fell unequally by design as well as by arithmetic.
Comparison hook
Against the great cities of Topic 1.1 and 2.1: Song Kaifeng, Baghdad and Constantinople reached comparable sizes with functioning water supply, markets and sanitation, because they grew over centuries under states that built and maintained them. The variable is not size but the rate of growth relative to the authority capable of building for it.

Terms to use precisely

Urbanization
The shift to a majority urban population, which Britain completed first across the nineteenth century.
Back-to-back housing
Dwellings sharing three walls, with windows on one side only and no through ventilation, built where no regulation set a floor.
Municipal corporation
The town government, in many cases designed for a market town and lacking the authority to build for an industrial city.
Public Health Act
The 1848 legislation beginning the construction of a state capable of addressing the sanitary crisis.
Anonymity
The condition of a city of strangers, which weakens the informal social control a village exercises.
04

Why the Water Killed People

1831 to 1866  ·  Cholera and typhoid

The success criteria ask specifically why overcrowded tenements without clean water or sewers produced cholera and typhoid, and the answer is a mechanism you can state in two sentences. Both diseases spread by the fecal-oral route, and a city with no sewers puts its waste into the water it drinks.

The mechanism

Cholera is caused by a bacterium ingested in contaminated water or food. It causes catastrophic diarrhea, and death follows from dehydration, sometimes within hours, which is why it terrified people in a way that endemic tuberculosis did not: a person could be well at breakfast and dead by evening. The infected material passes into the environment, and where sanitation is absent it reaches the water supply, which infects the next person. Typhoid works the same way, through contaminated water and food, more slowly.

Now put that mechanism in the city of section 03. Waste goes into cesspools and privies. Cesspools leak into the ground, and courts drain into ditches and streams. Water is drawn from shallow wells in the same ground, or piped by private companies from rivers into which the city's sewage flows, sometimes downstream of the outfall. Households share a standpipe running for a few hours a day, so water is stored in open vessels in crowded rooms. Every one of those steps closes the loop between what leaves a body and what enters the next one, and the density means one case reaches hundreds.

Then the perverse detail that makes this a good teaching case. Building proper sewers to flush waste out of the streets made the epidemics worse in the short term, because the sewers discharged into the Thames, and the Thames was where the water companies drew from. A sanitary improvement carried out under a wrong theory of disease moved the contamination from the street to the drinking supply, which is why the mechanism and not merely the effort is what has to be understood.

Britain had major cholera epidemics in 1831 to 1832, 1848 to 1849, 1853 to 1854 and 1866, with tens of thousands of deaths each time, and the disease had arrived from South Asia along the trade and troop routes of an expanding empire, which is a connection to Unit 6 worth noting: the same integration that moved cotton moved pathogens, exactly as the Topic 2.6 chapter describes for an earlier network.

How it was worked out, and what fixed it

The prevailing explanation was miasma theory, that disease arose from foul air given off by filth. It fitted the observation that disease was worst where the smell was worst, and it was wrong about the route while being right that filth was the problem, which is why sanitary reformers acting on it still did enormous good. The Topic 5.8 chapter has Chadwick, the reform movement and Bazalgette's sewers; what belongs here is how the mechanism itself was established.

John Snow argued that cholera was water-borne and demonstrated it in 1854 in Soho by mapping deaths against the pump they drew from, and, more powerfully, in a study comparing households in the same streets supplied by two different water companies, one drawing from a sewage-contaminated stretch of the Thames and one from further upstream, which found death rates several times higher among the first company's customers. That second study is the stronger evidence, because the households were otherwise similar in air, income and neighborhood, so the water was the only variable that differed. Snow did not persuade the profession immediately; germ theory, developed by Pasteur and Koch, who identified the cholera bacterium in 1883, supplied the explanation that made his result inevitable.

What actually ended the epidemics was engineering: intercepting sewers that carried waste far downstream, filtered water supplied under pressure, and eventually municipal ownership of the supply. Bazalgette's London system, funded after the Great Stink of 1858 made the river intolerable to Parliament itself, is the monument. Mortality in British cities improved substantially in the last third of the century, and clean water and sanitation are the largest identifiable reason.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
The fecal-oral loop closed by density. The mechanism is that cholera and typhoid pass out of one person and into the next through water, so a settlement that puts its waste into cesspools and rivers and draws its drinking water from the same ground and the same rivers connects every household’s waste to every other household’s cup, and packing people tightly enough turns a single case into an epidemic.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Sanitation was not the only factor in urban mortality, since diet, overcrowding, tuberculosis, occupational disease and infant mortality all contributed, and improvement came from several changes together.
Comparison hook
Against the Black Death in Topic 2.6: both are epidemics that traveled along trade routes into dense settlements, and the difference is that this one was solved. Cholera was identified, explained and engineered out within a few decades by a society that could build sewers and afford them, which is industrial technology curing an industrial disease.

Terms to use precisely

Cholera
A water-borne bacterial disease killing by dehydration within hours, epidemic in Britain in 1831, 1848, 1853 and 1866.
Fecal-oral route
Transmission from waste into drinking water and food, the mechanism that made an unsewered dense city lethal.
Miasma theory
The belief that disease arose from foul air, wrong about the route, right that filth mattered, and the basis of early reform.
John Snow
The physician who demonstrated water-borne cholera in 1854, decisively by comparing customers of two water companies.
Intercepting sewer
The engineering solution carrying waste far downstream of the water intake, the change that ended the epidemics.

Building an Answer That Scores

Each card is a full argument: the claim, the specific evidence, and the reason. The second and third answer the two success criteria that ask you to explain why rather than to describe.

Structure

Middle-class status came from a source of income, not an amount

The middle class ran from factory owners and bankers through engineers, doctors and managers down to clerks and schoolteachers, united by income drawn from business, qualification or salary rather than inherited title or rent from land, which is a position the older order of birth and land had no category for. Its markers were deliberate and visible: a house away from the works, a servant, a parlor, schooling, and a wife who did not earn. Note that a clerk might earn less than a skilled engineer and count himself in it while placing the engineer out of it, which shows the category was social as much as economic. The working class sold labor for wages, and what defined its life was less the size of the wage than its insecurity, since injury or a downturn meant destitution within weeks and after 1834 relief was governed by a workhouse built to be worse than the worst job, held over applicants even where, as usually happened, they were relieved at home instead.

Causation

Separate spheres describes the households that could afford it

The doctrine assigned men the public world and women the home, and withdrawing a woman’s earnings requires a household able to live on one income, so a non-earning wife became the clearest visible proof that a family had reached that level. Working-class households needed every earner, so women worked in mills, workshops, agriculture, mines until the 1842 ban and above all in domestic service, the largest single female occupation of the century, and married women took in laundry, lodgers and sewing that the census never recorded. The same ideology therefore produced opposite lives and then supplied the vocabulary in which working-class women were criticized for neglecting a domestic role their household economy made impossible.

Mechanism

Every urban challenge follows from one rate of growth

Manchester went from about 25,000 in 1772 to about 300,000 by 1850, and pipes, drains, streets and government do not multiply because people arrive. Housing shortage follows because dwellings cannot be built that fast, so rents rise and what gets built meets the cheapest specification a market with no building regulation will bear, which is what back-to-backs and inhabited cellars are. Infrastructure shortfall follows because water was sold privately to those who could pay, drainage was a parish matter, and the corporation was designed for a market town. Filth follows from privies shared by dozens of households with no collection service. And crime statistics rose alongside the number of police counting them, so read them as measuring several changes at once.

Evidence

Two water companies on one street settle the question

Cholera and typhoid pass from one person to the next through contaminated water, so a city storing waste in leaking cesspools and drawing water from the same ground, or from a river below its own sewage outfall, connects every household’s waste to every other household’s cup, and density turns one case into an epidemic. The proof is Snow’s South London study of 1854: competing companies had laid pipes house by house years earlier, so neighboring households alike in air, income and diet received water from different sources for no health-related reason, and when one company moved its intake upstream of the sewage and the other did not, mortality among the two sets of customers diverged enormously. Building sewers under miasma theory had first made things worse by discharging into the Thames the water companies drew from.

Topic 5.10

The Question That Runs Both Ways

In 1750 most people on earth farmed, moved at the speed of a horse and lived under someone who inherited the right to rule them. By 1900 a third of that had changed completely, a third had changed its form and kept its shape, and a third had not moved at all. This chapter is how to tell which is which, and how to write a thesis that takes a position instead of listing both.

Go to the Topic 5.10 lesson  ·  Back to contents

How to Use This

This chapter does not re-teach the unit. Section 01 is the changes in the form an essay needs them, each with a mechanism. Section 02 is the continuities with the reason each counts as one. Section 03 is the method for deciding, and section 04 is a full thesis written out with its own counterargument, which is what the third success criterion is asking for.

  1. 01 Three changes: each with the mechanism that made it matter, not a label.
  2. 02 Three continuities: and why each is continuity rather than change.
  3. 03 The method: four questions that decide which side a fact belongs on.
  4. 04 A worked thesis: a position, both sides supported, and the reasoning stated.
  5. Then the closing section, which turns all of it into comparison sentences you can write.
01

Three Changes, Each With Its Mechanism

c. 1750 to 1900  ·  What actually broke

The success criteria ask you to name changes and tie each to a key concept, and tying means showing the causal link rather than filing the fact under a heading. Three will do more work than ten, if each one is written with the mechanism attached.

Energy, and everything downstream of it

The change: production stopped being limited by muscle, water and wind and began running on stored fossil energy.

Why it matters, mechanically: every economy before this one had a ceiling set by how much work living things and moving water could do in a year, and that ceiling is why output per person had risen so slowly for so long. Coal removes it, because a seam represents millions of years of accumulated energy available all at once. That is the single fact under everything else in Unit 5: the factory of Topic 5.3, the railway and telegraph of Topic 5.5, the cities of Topic 5.9 and the military gap that opens in Unit 6 are all consequences of an energy source that does not run out at the end of the season.

Tie it: this is the industrial economy key concept in its strongest form, and the environmental key concept as well, since a species burning fossil carbon at scale begins here, as the Topic 5.5 chapter records.

The wage relationship, and the political ideas it produced

The change: the typical relationship between a worker and the means of production inverted. Before, most people had access to some productive property, a strip of land, a workshop, a loom in the parlor; after, most people in industrial societies owned none and sold hours instead.

Why it matters, mechanically: as the Topic 5.6 chapter sets out, a person with no productive property has exactly one thing to withhold, which makes collective action the characteristic form of industrial politics and makes the legal treatment of combination, in Topic 5.8, the decisive question of the century. It also produced ideologies that had not existed before: socialism and Marxism are answers to a question that could not have been asked of a society of peasants and craftsmen.

Tie it: social structures and governance both, since this is the origin of class as the organizing political category and of the state's new responsibility for welfare, from the Factory Acts to Bismarck's pensions.

The collapse of distance, and a genuinely global economy

The change: the cost of moving goods and the time taken to move information both fell by orders of magnitude, through railways, steamships, the Suez Canal and the telegraph.

Why it matters, mechanically: the Topic 4.8 chapter argues that the world became connected in the sixteenth century in the sense that a closed circuit existed. This is different and it is worth stating as the difference: connection became cheap, which means ordinary bulk goods rather than luxuries, and it became fast, which means prices in Bombay and Liverpool move together in a day. That is what turns a network of trade into a single market, and it is why an Argentine harvest could lower a German farmer's income.

Tie it: economic systems and technology, and it is also the mechanism that made the imperialism of Unit 6 practicable, since an empire is only governable at the speed its orders travel.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Removing an energy ceiling. The mechanism is that every pre-industrial economy was limited to the work that muscle, water and wind could perform in a given year, so output per person could only rise slowly, and a coal seam is stored energy accumulated over geological time that can be spent at any rate the machinery allows, which lifts the constraint that had bounded production for the whole of this course.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
The gains were distributed unevenly by region and by class, and the first generations of industrial workers, as Topic 5.3 records, largely did not receive them.
Comparison hook
Against Champa rice in Topic 1.1 and the potato in Topic 4.8: both raised the ceiling by increasing calories per acre, which supports more people at roughly the same standard. Coal is different in kind, because it raises output per person rather than the number of persons, and that distinction is the sharpest available answer to why this is the change and those were expansions.

Terms to use precisely

Energy ceiling
The pre-industrial limit set by muscle, water and wind, which fossil fuel removed.
Wage relationship
The arrangement in which a worker owns no productive property and sells hours, the basis of industrial class politics.
Cheap connection
The collapse of freight cost and message time, which distinguishes the nineteenth-century world market from earlier trade networks.
Mechanism
The causal step showing what a change made possible, which is what turns a named fact into an argument.
Key concept
The College Board category a change is tied to, which requires showing the causal link rather than naming the bucket.
02

Three Continuities, and Why They Count

c. 1750 to 1900  ·  What held

A continuity is not a thing that failed to change. It is a structure that persists while its content changes completely, and saying which is the structure and which is the content is the whole of this part of the answer.

Steep hierarchy, with new parties to it

The continuity: a small group controlled most of the productive wealth and most of the political power, and a large majority worked for them with little of either.

Why it counts: compare a landlord and tenant in 1750 with a factory owner and worker in 1880. The names, the legal basis and the setting are entirely different, and the shape is the same: a propertied few, a working many, an enormous gap in wealth and security, and political institutions weighted toward the top. The Topic 5.6 chapter describes a new elite of capital displacing an elite of land, and displacing an elite is not the same as removing a hierarchy. That is the sentence a grader is looking for.

The honest complication, which strengthens the answer rather than weakening it: the terms did change in ways that mattered. Legal serfdom ended across Europe, Russia included in 1861; slavery was abolished across the Atlantic world; hereditary status gave way to a hierarchy that was formally open. So the correct claim is precise: hierarchy persisted as a structure and became economic and formally open rather than legal and closed, which is continuity of shape with change of mechanism.

The rights argument, and the position of most of the world

The continuity of the rights struggle. The Topic 5.1 chapter identifies the move, holding a general principle to its own terms, and every campaign in this unit runs it: revolutionaries against monarchs, the enslaved against enslavers, Chartists and unionists against property qualifications and combination law, women against a franchise defended in universal language. The parties change constantly and the argument does not, which is exactly what a continuity is. And it is a continuity that continues past this unit, since the anticolonial movements of Units 6 and 8 use the identical move against the empires that taught it to them.

The continuity of most people's lives. This one is worth naming because it corrects the unit's center of gravity. In 1900, the great majority of people on earth still farmed, still lived in villages, and still worked with tools their grandparents would have recognized. Industrialization was concentrated in a handful of regions, for the reasons the Topic 5.4 chapter gives, and outside them the nineteenth century did not transform daily labor. The changes reached those regions in a different form, as demand for cotton, rubber, guano and grain, as railways built to the coast, and as debt, all of which reshaped economies without industrializing them.

Writing that continuity is one of the most reliable ways to demonstrate a global perspective rather than a European one, and it is defensible with the evidence already in this unit.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Structure persists, content changes. The mechanism is that a social arrangement can keep its shape, a few holding wealth and power over a working many, while every particular of it is replaced: the basis shifts from land to capital, the legal form from inherited status to open competition, and the setting from an estate to a factory, so a claim of continuity has to name the structure and a claim of change has to name the content.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
Pitched too high, any structure persists and the claim becomes unfalsifiable, so a continuity is only worth writing if you can also state what would have counted as its ending.
Comparison hook
Against Topic 4.7’s continuity-and-change argument: there the hierarchy kept its shape and changed its axis from religion and occupation to ancestry. Here it keeps its shape again and changes its axis from birth to capital. The same analytical move works in two units, which is a sign it is a method rather than a fact about one period.

Terms to use precisely

Continuity
A structure that persists while its content changes, which is what must be named for the claim to work.
Formally open hierarchy
A stratification with no legal barrier to movement, which replaced legally closed status without reducing the gap.
The rights move
Holding an accepted general principle to its own terms, used by every excluded group in this unit and beyond it.
Agrarian majority
The great majority of the world's people still farming in 1900, the continuity that corrects a Europe-centered account.
Anthropometric evidence
Height data from recruitment and prison records, which tracks childhood nutrition and tests claims about living standards.
03

Four Questions That Decide Which Side a Fact Belongs On

A method  ·  For any extent-of-change prompt

Most facts in this unit can be argued as continuity or as change, and a student who notices that usually panics. It is the opposite of a problem: it is the opening, because specifying which reading you mean and why is the analytical move the prompt is actually testing.

The four questions

1. At what level? Slavery is the clearest case. At the level of the institution, abolition across the Atlantic world is an enormous change. At the level of coerced labor, indentured servitude, debt peonage, the Congo rubber system of Topic 5.5 and the mita's descendants continue, so the practice persists in new legal forms. Both are true, and the sentence that scores says which level it is pitched at.

2. For whom? A Lancashire mill worker, a Bengali handloom weaver, an American plantation laborer, a Japanese farmer under the land tax and a Congolese rubber tapper are all in this unit, and the extent of change is wildly different for each. A claim that names its population is stronger than a claim about "society."

3. Over what span? From 1750 to 1800, very little has happened outside a few British counties. From 1750 to 1900, the world economy is unrecognizable. Prompts carry dates and the dates are part of the question.

4. Compared with what? Change is a comparison and is meaningless without a baseline. Compared with the century before, the nineteenth is a transformation. Compared with the twentieth, its technologies look continuous with what preceded them. Say what your baseline is.

Running the questions on one fact

Take a single fact and watch the four questions produce four different defensible answers, which is what makes them a method rather than a checklist.

The fact: women entered factory work in large numbers.

At what level? At the level of whether women worked, this is continuity, and the Topic 5.9 chapter says so: women had always worked. At the level of where and on whose terms, it is a genuine change, since the workplace separated from the home for the first time.

For whom? For working-class women it meant wage work away from home. For middle-class women it meant the opposite, withdrawal from paid work as a marker of status. One economic change, two opposite outcomes, decided by what a household could afford.

Over what span? Across the whole century it is change, since married women's property rights, education and eventually the vote follow. Across the first fifty years it is mostly a change of setting without a change of position.

Compared with what? Compared with the household economy immediately before, the factory is a break. Compared with the position of women in the societies of Units 1 to 4, the fundamentals of legal subordination and domestic responsibility are strikingly persistent until very late in this period.

Four answers, all supportable, and none of them contradicts the others because each is a different question. Writing one of them explicitly, with the qualifier attached, is what an extent-of-change prompt rewards.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
Qualified comparison. The mechanism is that continuity and change are not properties of a fact but of a comparison, so a fact has no fixed answer until you specify the level, the population, the time span and the baseline, and stating those four is what converts an apparent contradiction into a thesis with a defensible scope.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
It is a method for structuring an argument, not a substitute for evidence. Every level you specify still has to be supported with a particular case.
Comparison hook
Against Topic 4.8’s method section: there the resolution was that the connections were transformed and the centers were not, which is the same move made once. Here it is generalized into four questions, and running them is how you find that kind of sentence for yourself instead of memorizing one.

Terms to use precisely

Level of claim
Whether you mean the institution, the practice or the structure, which decides whether a fact reads as change or continuity.
Scope
The population a claim covers, which a strong thesis names rather than implying everyone.
Periodization
The span a claim covers, which is part of the prompt and changes the answer.
Baseline
The point of comparison against which change is measured, without which a change claim has no meaning.
Qualified thesis
A position stated with its level, scope and span attached, which is what an extent-of-change prompt rewards.
04

A Thesis, Written Out

The third criterion  ·  A position, both sides, the reasoning

The success criteria ask for a defensible thesis that takes a position on the extent of change, supports both sides with specific evidence, and explains the reasoning. Here is one, written out, so you can see the shape rather than infer it.

The prompt, and a thesis that answers it

Prompt: Evaluate the extent to which industrialization transformed societies in the period from 1750 to 1900.

A weak thesis: "Industrialization changed society a lot, but some things stayed the same." It takes no position, names nothing, and could preface an essay about any period in the course.

A defensible thesis: "Industrialization transformed how societies produced and where their people lived more completely than any change since agriculture, but it left the basic structure of social hierarchy intact, replacing an elite of land with an elite of capital while the majority continued to work for others with little property or political power, and outside a small number of industrializing regions it altered what the world's farmers grew and sold without changing that they farmed."

Notice what that sentence does. It takes a position, that the change was profound in one dimension and limited in another. It specifies the dimensions, production and settlement against social structure. It names its scope, distinguishing industrializing regions from everywhere else. And it gives the grader a map of the essay, because each clause is a paragraph.

Supporting both sides, and stating the reasoning

The change side, with evidence. Britain passed from a majority rural to a majority urban society within a century, and Manchester grew from about 25,000 to about 300,000 between 1772 and 1850. Production moved from households working at their own pace to factories running on the clock, after Arkwright concentrated workers and machines at Cromford in 1771. Watt's rotary engine of 1781 and Bessemer's converter of 1856 removed the energy and materials ceilings, and the telegraph from 1844 separated the speed of information from the speed of transport for the first time in history. Entirely new political ideologies, socialism and Marxism, appeared to explain conditions that had not previously existed.

The continuity side, with evidence. A new elite displaced an old one rather than dissolving the hierarchy: the Reform Act of 1832 admitted the middle class to the political nation and left the working class outside, and Chartism was rejected. Wealth stayed concentrated at the top throughout, on the tax and probate evidence. Coerced labor persisted in new forms after abolition, in the Congo rubber system and in indenture and debt peonage. And in 1900 the great majority of the world's people still farmed, since industrialization reached a short list of regions and reached the rest as demand for raw materials, as railways built to the coast and as debt.

The reasoning, which is the part most answers omit. These two sides do not cancel, and the reason is that they describe different levels. Industrialization changed the means by which wealth was produced and the places where people lived, and it did so with a completeness that has few parallels. It did not change the relationship between those who own productive property and those who work it, and in the regions it did not industrialize it changed what was produced rather than how. A transformation of means with a persistence of relations is a coherent position, and it is why the nineteenth century produced both the greatest increase in output in history and the largest movements demanding that its benefits be shared.

Use this in your answer
Strongest tool, with its mechanism
A thesis that maps its own essay. The mechanism is that a thesis stating a position in clauses, each naming a dimension and its scope, tells a reader what every paragraph will argue before they reach it, so the evidence that follows reads as support for a claim rather than as a list of facts, which is the difference the rubric is measuring.
Best evidence of exclusion or limit
A well-built thesis with thin evidence still fails. The structure is what makes evidence count, and it does not substitute for having any.
Comparison hook
Against Topic 3.4 and Topic 4.8: those chapters end on the same skill, holding several cases against one question and stating what varies in the thesis rather than discovering it in the last paragraph. Three units in a row end this way because it is the one technique that transfers to every essay you will write in this course.

Terms to use precisely

Defensible thesis
A position that could be argued against, stated with the dimensions and scope it covers.
Concession
The deliberate statement of the strongest evidence against your position, followed by why it does not defeat it.
Line of reasoning
The explanation of why the evidence supports the claim, which is what separates an argument from a list.
Dimension
The aspect a claim is about, production, settlement, social structure, which lets one thesis hold change and continuity together.
Complexity
Recognizing that a question has defensible answers on more than one side, and resolving it rather than balancing it.

Building an Answer That Scores

Each card is a full argument: the claim, the specific evidence, and the reason. The last one is a complete thesis with its concession attached, which is the deliverable this topic is asking for.

Change

Coal removed a ceiling every previous economy had lived under

Every economy in this course before the nineteenth century was limited to the work that muscle, water and wind could do in a year, which is why output per person had risen so slowly for so long. A coal seam is stored energy accumulated over geological time and spendable at whatever rate the machinery allows, so the constraint disappears. Everything else in Unit 5 sits downstream of that: the factory at Cromford in 1771, Watt’s rotary motion in 1781, Bessemer steel in 1856, railways, the telegraph, and cities that grew twelvefold in two generations. Note the contrast with Champa rice and the potato, which raised calories per acre and therefore the number of people supported; coal raised output per person, which is a change in kind rather than in scale.

Continuity

Displacing an elite is not removing a hierarchy

Compare a landlord and tenant in 1750 with a factory owner and worker in 1880: the names, the legal basis and the setting are entirely different and the shape is identical, a propertied few, a working many, a large gap in wealth and security, and political institutions weighted to the top. The Reform Act of 1832 admitted the middle class to the political nation and left the working class outside, Chartism was rejected, and tax and probate evidence shows wealth concentrated at the top throughout. The honest qualification strengthens the claim: legal serfdom and slavery ended and status became formally open, so hierarchy persisted as a structure while its basis moved from birth and land to capital.

Method

A fact has no answer until you say which comparison you mean

Women entering factory work reads as continuity at the level of whether women worked, since they always had, and as change at the level of where and on whose terms, since the workplace separated from the home. It meant wage work away from home for working-class women and withdrawal from paid work as a status marker for middle-class women, so the population named decides the answer. Across the whole century it is change, since property rights, education and the vote follow; across the first fifty years it is mostly a change of setting. And measured against the household economy immediately before it is a break, while measured against Units 1 to 4 the legal subordination is strikingly persistent. Four defensible answers, four different questions, and naming which one you mean is the analytical move.

Thesis

A transformation of means with a persistence of relations

Industrialization transformed how societies produced and where their people lived more completely than any change since agriculture, and left the basic structure of social hierarchy intact, replacing an elite of land with an elite of capital while the majority continued working for others with little property or power, and outside a small number of regions it altered what the world’s farmers grew and sold without changing that they farmed. The two halves do not cancel because they are pitched at different levels: the means of production and the places people lived changed almost completely, the relationship between owners and workers did not, and where industry never arrived the change was in the crop rather than the work. That is also why the same century produced the largest rise in output in history and the largest movements demanding it be shared.